Paynes Pizza & More image 1Paynes Pizza & More image 2Paynes Pizza & More image 3Paynes Pizza & More image 4Paynes Pizza & More image 5Paynes Pizza & More image 6Paynes Pizza & More image 7Paynes Pizza & More image 8Paynes Pizza & More image 9Paynes Pizza & More image 10

Categories


Phone: +1 740-363-9040
Site: http://www.paynespizza.net/
Opening hours
  • Monday:10:30AM–9:30PM
  • Tuesday:10:30AM–9:30PM
  • Wednesday:10:30AM–9:30PM
  • Thursday:10:30AM–9:30PM
  • Friday:10:30AM–10:30PM
  • Saturday:10:30AM–10:30PM
  • Sunday:10:30AM–9:30PM
Edit info

Total reviews rating 4.2

199 Reviews for Paynes Pizza & More 2023:

Review №1

2022-06-02

Dining room is clean but has an old school diner feel which I love. Bathrooms are also tidy. I had a chicken wrap once which was generous on toppings, but a bit dry. Their pizza is decently priced. They dont use a lot of sauce, but that suits my taste. Not a big fan of lots of sauce. It reminds me of a classic pizza. Good and filling! Also, I havent had the buffet, but I will next time I come.

Review №2

2022-06-15

I love their chicken Parmesan and my wife likes their Stromboli. Only complaint was that the pizza looked a little over cooked... cheese was dark... and the second time my wife had the Stromboli, she felt the onions were in too large portions (large chunks). Otherwise, enjoyed it... weve had their food twice.

Review №3

2018-06-26

Got a pizza (Abbie’s Pig ) and wings ( Buffalo ), the food was not that great. The pizza and wings were both about the same quality as a frozen tombstone pizza and microwaved Tyson wings. The service was good, they seemed friendly and attentive. But unless you enjoy frozen pizza that the toppings fall off of when you pick it up I would not recommend this pizza place.

Review №4

2021-06-29

Average pizza place. didnt like how pizza hut and papa johns answered their phones so went here instead. i refuse to give money to those with no manners or etiquette so this place lucked out. not impressed overall. better than pizza hut. papa johns is better but couldnt trust them over the phone for even a pizza order for some reason so paynes ended up with my $11.

Review №5

2022-04-06

Really great sandwiches and subs. Pizza is good as well but nothing to really exceptional about it. The steak burger and the Philly is amazing!

Review №6

2021-08-25

Neither quality NOR quantity when it comes to these toppings. Our pizza cost $5 more due to toppings, and yet there is hardly any to account for that cost. The pizza was dry, cold and thoroughly unappetizing, and it looks like they only topped the very center of the pizza, with the rest of the surface ignored, making a ring of toppings half the size of the pie. There is no detectable flavor in the crust or sauce, and the cheese seems especially tough and rubbery. Overall, I would not recommend this place to anyone whom has a budget or taste buds.

Review №7

2022-05-24

Salad is fresh and mothwatering. plenty of evefythingmeat. chef Salad. italian sub fulfill your ideal sub taste. the bread is even great . the breakfast. is software and sweet

Review №8

2022-07-15

I always enjoy going here. Food and employees are great!

Review №9

2022-02-25

Went there for the pizza buffet tonight arrived around 5:10 they had no pizza ready for the buffet, then they were bringing out 1 pizza at a time when there was 6 guys and a couple woman. Frustrating!!

Review №10

2022-04-22

Good pizza for a good price. Can occasionally be difficult to get through to but the staff is friendly in the pizza is usually ready fairly quickly. This location can be a bit tricky to drive through but definitely worth it. Daily specials especially make it worthwhile.

Paynes Pizza & More in other cities: