Kerbside pickup
Yes
Masseys Pizza in Lancaster
Categories
Location on the map
Lancaster, Fairfield County, Ohio, US
Service options
No-contact delivery
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Fast service
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
All you can eat
Yes
Beer
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 740-653-6633
Site: https://www.masseys.pizza/lancaster
Site: https://www.masseys.pizza/lancaster
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–10PM
- Tuesday:11AM–10PM
- Wednesday:11AM–10PM
- Thursday:11AM–10PM
- Friday:11AM–11PM
- Saturday:11AM–11PM
- Sunday:11AM–10PM
Masseys Pizza in other cities:
Comments (159)
The best taco pizza I have had so far and i had tried from Lancaster to newlex and Logan to athens and zansvilly
Absolutely the worst pizza I have ever had. We ordered two large pizzas and they were both burnt. We also ordered the pretzel sticks, burnt as well. The pepperoni bites were undercooked, and the stromboli was not a stromboli but a calzone and was cooked so crispy and crunchy I thought I was going to break a tooth. The last thing we ordered was the garlic bread dippers and that was just bread and cheese with some garlic sauce, pretty ordinary. Definitely would recommend not wasting your money on this place. The food here rates below any gas station pizza Ive ever had AND any frozen pizza from a supermarket.
Friendly staff great service clean bathrooms loved the blt pizza just would have been nice to have a spatula to get it out with. Other than that great place to eat.
Ive been eating Masseys Pizza since 1978 and the quality has never changed. It is my go to pizza and when I was living out of state every time I came home for a visit I had to get a Masseys Pizza. Nothing in Wisconsin, Indiana, Missouri or Oklahoma touched the flavor and quality of Masseys.
Hands down one of my favorite places to eat in Central Ohio. Incredible pizza and wings, draft beer always available and great service! 5 out of 5 and a must try if youre cruising through lancaster or just want some place for a chill dinner.
Pizza was burnt this time usually good maybe just a bad day lol
Decent pizza. The pictures look great. Either there was not enough sauce and the crust sponged it up or its a very bland sauce. There is a great foundation for a superior pie but one ingredient can change that for some peoples taste.
Excellent establishment. Exceptionally clean and the pizza was outta this world. I got the cauliflower gluten free crust and I was blown away. My pizza was generously loaded with toppings, so much that it was falling off, but no worries I ate every bite. Prices were very reasonable as well. Make this your go to place for pizza if you live in the area or like us, just passing through.
Met my niece and her husband for some drinks and Vikki and Glenn are impressed the last time they were there. We had the Mozzarella and green peppers pizza. It was so good we ordered another one! Very clean and staff were helpful and pizza came out fast and hot.
Very good subs and salads. The 2 guys working were very pleasant
Delicious food and an absolutely lovely staff.
I ordered a sub from this place tonight and it was absolutely horrible. 🤢The bun was hard the meat looked like it had been sitting around for hours. I will never be eating there again.
Best pizza in Lancaster. Great service!
Mid-day buffet will please & the staff will serve you well. Enjoy all that you want, but please dont waste any food. Extensive menu & likely the chefs will create any dish you desire. There is a bar (although unsure about the libations served?) & amusements, still a family atmosphere. Much about sports & such, Go Bucks!
I was a bit leery of this new fad for cauliflower crust everyone is talking about... I like raw and cooked cauliflower but haven’t been a fan of where cauliflower replaces things... I was pleasantly surprised and impressed! This crust puts a new spin on cauliflower crust and getting a great pizza and lower carbs! It’s a win win.
This was out first time going to Masseys Pizza. I got the califlower crust and it was amazing! My family got a regular pizza and it too was awesome. The staff was so nice and so informative on everything we asked. We will definitely be back again.
I bought the chicken bacon ranch 8 pizza just to try. They were very generous with the toppings which I appreciate considering the price however the bottom of the pizza was burnt, and I mean a good 1/8 solid char. Very bad first and last impression!
We order food from here all the time. We also live in Carroll Ohio and they will deliver to here. We love this pizza but the last 3 times they have messed up our order or put WAY to much corn meal under it. For that reason they only get 4 stars. So its not a food problem its a people problem. If they tighten up that kitchen issue its 5 stars.
Ive ordered subs from there from time to time and theyve been great. However the last 3 times Ive ordered, its always missing an ingredient or theres one I didnt ask for. Ive even told them so as to make sure but its still wrong. Very dissatisfied
Masseys is always good on a normal day. I tried the new cauliflower crust. First off it was 18 dollars for a 10 in and it wasnt good at all. The Pepperonis were thick on the ends. The crust was hard you couldnt chew it. I called back they usually right there mistakes but this guy was like well you ordered it its not my problem. Which is true. I will not be ordering that crust anymore. It didnt even have the corn meal on the bottom. Whatever they use. It tastes like cardboard.
Ordered 6 large pizzas for a birthday party. Got home and one of them was completely burnt. We could not eat it. Will not go there again
Dirty outside. My daughter ordered the chicken parmesan and it was drenched in pizza sauce and had a bread tie baked in it. Maybe I should have led with that. We didnt know until we got home to eat, which is 45 minutes outside lancaster. Clean this place up. Quit standing out front smoking. Pay attention to your employees and do a better job in general.
Was told our pizza would be ready in 30 minutes. Went in to pick up after about 25 minutes and had to wait for another 30 minutes. Once we got home to eat, the Mexican pizza had no real flavor. Usually, we order the Godfather pizza which is delicious!
Pizza is really great. BUT service not good. This evening we waited 45 minutes for dine in pizza. Several other customers were complaining about the long wait time. And its always cold in there, have to eat with your coat on. Wont go back. Have eaten here off and on for couple years but not worth the wait time.
Good food, friendly staff. Definitely need to bring the lunch buffet back
The food is always fresh, hot and delicious! Staff is super friendly!
Love their cauliflower crust, gluten free pizza.
I especially love the cauliflower crust pizza. But the regular pizza crust is very good too. Also very good wings.
People were rude, we got there at 9 closes at 11 and a girl who works there that was sitting at a table said ughh... but i just cleaned everything when we asked if it was ok to eat inside. The others werent so friendly either. Other than our cheese sticks being cold the food was ok.
We ordered a Godfather pizza tonight, the first in a while. I must say it was the best we have ever had.. Seasoned crust, the toppings were wonderful.... Thank you Masseys.....
Ordered a large pizza and salad at 8:03 for delivery on 11/5/20. It’s 9:18p No pizza. I called back and the guy said it was typed in as a pick up. Not good👎🏼
I like Masseys have since I was a kid. The franchise likes to cut the pizza their way instead of an original Masseys cut. Doesnt have the same amount of crumbs under the pie. While this may seem petty, its a part of the memory.
The pizza is out this world. Godfather, youre never want any bodys elses. The service in great to!!! Just make sure youre set to eat, for youre will not want anyone to ENJOY your pizza.
Our favorite is the deep dish Godfather. Full of toppings, pepperoni, Italian sausage, and cheeses....the taste is just great. Quality ingredients used ..
Excellent service. They have excellent wings and a variety of specialty pizzas. I especially like the chicken bacon ranch and white pizza.
Love this pizza! Always good no matter what we get here!
Fried Mushrooms were still frozen, took 15 minutes to get our drinks. Service was awful. Bloody Marys are not like theyre pictured. 10/10 would not eat again.
One of the best pizzas every. Workers have been there for ling time. Great place to eat!
Usually always a place to sit and enjoy a cold one when all the other restaurants are packed. Godfather pizza is very good, and lots of tvs.
It was good. Guy working was really sweet to my daughter and made the pizza right way. A good experience!
Pizza wasnt good and place is dirty the fountain drinks were good lol bout it though
Did not expect much as place was empty. Pizza was excellent. Toppings all the way to the crust
One of the best pizza places in town! I dropped a few of my other pizza places for masseys now. Cant beat the quality
Friendly service, great food. Everything you could want for pizza night out!
Cant complain about price. 7.99 with a drink and all u can eat pizza. Average pizza but still good.
Good food sucks the lunch buffet is no longer available.
The lunch buffet is really good and great price. Classic pizza flavor, subs are good too.
Good pizza. A little pricey. But its a nice place to have a long lunch.
Not the best, but very good. A little pricey. They have adult beverages , TVs, and booths inside. The atmosphere was sporty.
Great Pizza! One of my top favorites
Best pizza around! I drive down here from Groveport to get great service awesome food 👍🍺🇺🇸
I love Masseys good pizza and subs.. cold beer !
It was very good the last time I was there. Hopefully they reopen next week.We live out of town.
Pizza was hot, loved the thin crust, and the cornmeal on it. It was fresh. My husband loved it!
Awesome pizza place great food fast and friendly service the godfather is the best pizza around for sure
Very good..we didnt have the buffet but noticed it was being well attended to. Next time we will try.
Best pizza in Lancaster, Reynoldsburg and Whitehall!!! I love the crispy pepperoni and the cornmeal dusted crispy crust!!
Excellent pizza but they need to get a liquor license ;)
The crust hard and burnt on every Pizza I tried except for one . The sandwiches were okay people were friendly
Tons of pepperoni and cheese. Their signature crust, thin and crisp with the cornmeal on the bottom was great!
The pizza was great 👍
Best pepperoni pizza ever!
The lunch buffet was as awesome. 7.99 including drink! You cant beat that!
The pizza was great! The owners were awesome!
Love their pizza and their menu selections
A valiant attempt to compete with Dominos Pizzas carry-out specials but the food does not compare.
Always great service and great people love stopping here. For lunch buffet
Great pizza subs arent bad either
Great pizza. Good quality, friendly service.
Love Masseys pizza. Always perfect!
Never been there . Sorry. . Heard its great
Awesome
Just didnt like the food. Nice people tho.
There was way to much corn meal on the bottom of the pizza, its like youre just eating corn meal from the bag.
One star says it all about this dump
I think it was great! Not very good in the hospitality department though
Best pizza in Lancaster......
Hardly any chicken on my sub, the lasagna was still cold in the middle
Way better than Donatos, and any other pizza for that matter
Pizza is the best in town. Cauliflower crust is the bomb!
So yummy 😋
Filling our tummies during our lunch breaks at Furniture With A Heart!!!
Food was good. Enjoyed meeting with friends.
Great food. Normally do delivery.
Great Pizza lunch buffet - and under eight bucks!
First time trying it and it was awesome. Will diffently be back again
Been my favorite pizza since I was a kid.
LOTS of topping!, Cauliflower, glutenfree crust. Delicious.
Gotta love Masseys!
Burnt pizza on buffet pointed it out to them and they kept serving the same burnt pizza.
Great pizzas. Boneless wings a waste.of money.
Best Italian subs in lancastwr hands down
Not too bad for Tuesday night!
Delicious
Very good as usual. Love the lunch buffet.
The best pizza and salads in Lancaster!
My grandsons first Massey pizza.. reputation upheld!
It was good pizza, but expensive.
Masseys has the pizza . And I like pizza!
Fast service.sub was great.
Terrible customer service. Over priced pizza.
Absolutely best pizza in Lancaster
One of the best pies in central Ohio
OMG!! MASSEYS IS BY FAR, THE BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!
Always 100% never fail!!
Great buffet and clean location
Was there for the first time and was very satisfied!
Enjoyed everything we ordered.
It was a family place and had a good time
Top notch place!!! Treat you like family!
Pretty good...kinda pricey...
Food is awesome
Best pizza ever
Best thing in my area
I have all right pizza
Very good
Good. Fast.
Always great Pizza !
Love the atmosphere here
Ok pizza. Shocked at how much it costs.
Great food!
Always good pizza
Theres a monster under the porch
Best Pizza in Lancaster
Pizza was delicious!!
Great pizza
Really good food.
Pizza and Bourbon... Score!!!
Excellent pizza.
It was so yummy
Great pizza!
Great pizza.
Worst buffet
Excellent pizza
A Great Place to Eat
Always awesome😊
Good food.
Great pizza
Love!!!!!
Good pizza
Good food.
Good pizza
Pizza is the best
Was not a fan
Great place.
Great Pizza
Good pizza
Workers attitude
Great!!!!!
Total reviews rating 4.2
159 Reviews for Masseys Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-08-04Absolutely, without a doubt, Masseys Pizza makes the best pizza in Lancaster. Actually, all of their foods are scrumptious! Everything has superb taste! You cannot go wrong ordering anything on the menu. I highly recommend their food. You will totally be amazed!
Review №2
2022-04-23I had the thick crust, half Ham half Pepperoni pizza. Family loved the pepperoni, I really enjoyed the Ham and Cheese side. Fresh Ham. Pizza seasoned perfectly. Chef had been there 30 years. Really knows his stuff. Ill definitely go back.
Review №3
2022-04-10Love this place for their pizza and wing. Most meat on there wings and so damn good as their pizza are. Pizza has never changed since we went to the Sullivan Ave shop after football games in the 70s. I rate Massey a 10 outta 10 in Lancaster Ohio for keeping the traditional alive! Im glad I dont have to go all the way to the Westside of Columbus since they opened in Lancaster only wish they would bring back their lunch buffet!
Review №4
2022-05-04This Masseys Pizza awesome a great pizza! It taste alot how donatos used to taste before they screwed it up. Im not in the delivery area but it is always hot and ready when they tell me it will be ready. Best Pizza in Fairfield county.
Review №5
2022-06-08This place is the best! Especially if you go in and eat! Nothing like eating a good pizza thats hot out-the-oven!
Review №6
2022-01-25Good pizza and a nice place. I would have never went in but a friend insisted that I do and I was glad. Spacious and nice. The hall to the restroom is spooky LOL! They have motion detector lights that kick on when move along but it is a long dark hall way and its like you are in an episode of American Horror Story. I half expect Evan Peters or Jessica Lange to pop and get me just kidding it is just really surreal and a little bizarre but in a fun way.
Review №7
2022-04-04Staff was unfriendly, Restaurant was dirty, salad was terrible and pizza was ok. Should have walked out as soon as we got there. Don’t know how they stay in business.
Review №8
2022-04-17I really like there deep dish Chicago style pizza! You do need to request extra sauce though.
Review №9
2019-10-24Enjoyed the lunch buffet. Freshly maintained Masseys pizza and subs. Good variety/assortment.
Review №10
2022-06-28Cauliflower crust pizza was excellent. Thin,crisp,and delicious.