Credit cards
Yes
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in Columbus
Categories
Location on the map
Columbus, Franklin County, Ohio, US
Payments
Phone: +1 614-442-3310
Site: http://www.hydeparkrestaurants.com/
Site: http://www.hydeparkrestaurants.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:4:30–9PM
- Wednesday:4:30–9PM
- Thursday:4:30–9PM
- Friday:4:30–10PM
- Saturday:4:30–10PM
- Sunday:4–8PM
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in other cities:
Comments (199)
I went to this place 9/17 9/18 9/20 the 17th was good that’s why I went back on the 18th and it was ok experience besides me telling them I did not want Ceaser dressing and having to travel back to get it fixed. So the cheesecake was so good I came back a 3rd day and I want to say nope I will not be back! One the salad was really thin I had to ask for more salad mix. Then I checked the cheeses cake and it was mold on it !!! I went in side and she said she was sorry and she went to the back to get me new ones. She said she checked them but obviously not because when I got halfway home still mold on my she cheesecake white furry spots ... which would be the start of it sitting you can tell when cheesecake is old the crust is mushy and west and there is dew that starts to form and that exactly what I had ! I wish I would of checked before I left because I definitely would of got my money back this not ok with me! I don’t know if they thought that I wouldn’t care but I do and this it not how your treat your guest carry out or dining in! I could of gotten sick if I was not a picky person about my food! If you read this check your cheesecake cake that has been sitting to long smh!!
Everything was above and beyond amazing and we had a wonderful experience and look forward to going back.
Hyde Park continues to be one of my favorite steakhouses in Columbus. I prefer my steak medium rare and they do not disappoint. All steaks are topped with butter which blends perfectly with the slight char of the meat. My favorite cut here is the ribeye. Dont ruin it with sauce! If you need to drown your steak for some moronic reason head to Smith & Wollensky. You cant go wrong with any potatoe side, but I recommend the aug gratin which you share with friends at the table. You will get bread for the table; jump on the pretzel bread first or ask for extra. I typically skip the apps as the dinner is rather filling by itself. If I had to choose I would select the lobster bisque. The desserts are just ok and would expect more from a high end restaurant. Pass on the tempting cheesecake and select one of the other cake options. The lava cake they used to have was my go-to, but now I typically pass on dessert. I am there for the steak anyways. The Henderson Rd location is my favorite as the atmosphere feels old schools. Downtown is very trendy and hip. Dublin feels upscale. The meals are all the same just the ambience is different. If I am ranking Steak Houses in Columbus that I have been... (1) Hyde Park, (2) Avenue (3) Eddie Merlot - best desserts (4) J. Gilberts (5) The Top... Last place S&W.
Very good food. Extremely good attitude from the staff. A wonderful evening in a cozy atmosphere.
We sat at the bar and had dinner. I was driving, so no alcohol, but the food was fantastic. The only thing Id mention is that the Bleu cheese on the steak woody was overpowering. I scraped it off and the remnants were perfect. The steak was ridiculously tender and the bacon flavor was light, but delicious. Also, if youre a fan of Caesar with anchovies, the Caesar here was perfect!
We enjoyed our visit to Hyde Park. We had out of town visitors with us. They were impressed. Always a great experience,. You are well served with delicious meals. We have gone there for years. Looking forward to our next visit.
Great food and even better service! Colin was our waiter and was extremely attentive and friendly. My husband and I love coming to this location!
Steak was beautifully seasoned and perfectly cooked. I would not recommend french fries they are not steak fries they taste more like the new Wendys french fries. Both asparagus and creme brulee were delicious. Service was just ok. We received minimal attention. We could hear the other tables around us getting the daily special and other conversation we did not get from our server. He told us he was swamped.
Great food and wonderful wait staff. Reservations were made for the wrong location, but this location ended up being great for our large group.
Everything was good. This is a slower pace, no rushing. Time to talk with your dining companions. Servers are very attentive, they work as a team. If your water glass is empty the next person that walks by will fill your glass. Side are large enough for two. Baked potato weighed 1 pound. We found the background music a bit to much on the bouncy side considering the environment. Steaks were cooked perfectly.
Had a fantastic New Years Eve Dinner! Food and service was phenomenal. Best steak I ever had! Will definitely return.
Incredible food and incredible service. Never a bad meal here. Its always worth the price.
I never had a really well cooked steak before I came to Hyde park. Exceptional food, exceptional service. Great experience. (Take in mind I was not paying for the meal lol)
Excellent food, mediocre service. I forgive the service because it was NYE and the restaurant was full, but I was definitely disappointed by the service. Otherwise, exceptional appetizers and main courses.
Had the Salmon citrus. Husband had the Tomahawk. Better than High St. Location. Came from Cincinnati. We will be back. Ask for Eddie... Phenomenal waiter!!!!
Excellent food and the service was great. One of the best meals Ive ever had.
Amazing dinner with excellent service. 6 year anniversary and they had the table set up for us and a free dessert. Steaks were cooked to perfection! Will definitely be going back more.
Our wait staff was fantastic, especially our waiter Greg. The entire evening was top notch.
Highly disappointed. We had a 5:30 reservation that we made through open table. We reserved bar seating through the app. Upon arrival the hostess notified us that bar seating is not at the bar through the OpenTable app. So they sat us at one of the tables within the bar area. The happy hour at Hyde park is between 4 to 6 PM. We were sat at our table at 5:30 however we were not greeted by our server until 5:50.Which gave us 10 minutes to order a drink and our food during happy hour. We were not presented with a happy hour menu either when we were seated so I asked the hostess for one because we were sitting at a table in the bar and requested bar seating through the app, but the hostess informed me that the tables in the bar we’re not part of happy hour and could not receive happy hour pricing. We have been coming to Hyde Park for many years, I came here for my prom date when I was 17, over 20 some years ago. This by far was the most disappointing experience lack of communication and clearly miss leading information.
My church had reservations for a dinner meeting. Since I cant eat beef or pork I had salmon and a salad. It was absolutely delicious! Hope we hold our next outside meeting there!!
Such a wonderful experience and superb food. We go to Columbus for the ultimate restaurant experience.
My favorite ! Great service and beat filet I have ever had. Will be returning.
They took really really good care of us. I highly recommend Hyde Park!
My mom and I came in late wanting escargot. Weve been looking everywhere in Columbus and this is the best escargot I think I have had. We also got lobster bisque and that was phenomenal as well. The bartender was amazing. If I could give it more than 5 stars I would!
A steak house of excellence. I have eaten at several of the Hyde Park restaurants. This is the oldest in Columbus and still my favorite. From the moment you walk in until you leave you feel welcomed and appreciated. The menu is steak centric, however there are other offerings that I am sure are equally delicious. The escargot is excellent and a great starter. All side dishes are quite shareable and I cant describe how delicious they were. My favorite was the Gratin potatoes but the asparagus, Brussels sprouts and whipped potatoes were equally delightful. But the filet, oh the filet- it was the best Ive ever had. Tender, juicy and full of rich aged beef flavor with nary a sign of fat or gristle. Excellent wine menu that is easy to navigate with prices you would expect from a 5 star bovine shrine such as this. The dessert menu is simplistic, but well executed. We devoured the flourless chocolate cake, then got two orders to go. Great staff, incredible food, a wonderful experience. The bar is now very high for our next stop.
Really want to give like 3.5 stars:Pros: Good service from our server, Tim. Au gratin potatoes were amazing! The cake with the bananas (cant remember exact name) was delicious too.Cons: For a steakhouse, I thought my NY strip was sub par. Lobster mac and cheese was didnt have much flavor nor much lobster. Garlic mashed potatoes were pretty basic too
Hyde Park had great service and the staff was extremely welcoming and helpful really made the experience good! The food was also wonderful and cooked perfectly!
Okay, this is both a difficult review...and a simple one. Difficult because I dont know how to describe a perfect dining experience, as this is the first one Ive ever had. Easy, because it was perfect.I chose Hyde Park for my wifes birthday dinner, just her and I. Now, my record when choosing restaurants by myself is dubious. Sometimes its a hit, often times its not. With this being her birthday, and a milestone birthday at that, I had to make as near a perfect choice as possible. So, yeah, Ive been wracking my brain for the better part of a week. Had to be the right combination of intimacy, service, ambiance, and quality of food. Hyde Park delivered in spades. Our server, Jamal, was the definition of quality and kind and personable service. He could give classes, he was so good. The food was second to none. The atmosphere was sophisticated without being pretentious. As I said at the beginning, a perfect dining experience!
Went with family, son and his wife had an 37th wedding anniv. Food and service was super. Reason for four stars is it is rediculously expensive. A weeks income for five people to dine seems high to me, although it was good.
Birthday celebration- excellent service and attention by our server, Jurel! Food and libations superb- honestly, one of the best meals I, and everyone in our party has ever had! A night and meal to remember!
This place never disappoints. My wife and kids took me to the Upper Arlington one for fathers day and was flawless as usual. We have been going there for 20 years and quality service never changes. We love it!
I’ve had dine in here and the food and service was great. However, the take out game needs improvement. All the sides and the steaks I ordered were not cooked well and was a slight disappointment for me. Highly recommend dining in!
My wife and I went there for our anniversary. Enjoyed the Arlington location much more than dowtown. Great food, fantastic staff, and quite safety consious.We were seated beside the fireplace, with a card and rose petals on the table for the occasion. Everything perfect.It was our first visit to this location, but we are heading back to check out their happy hour this week.Thank you for making our anniversary wonderful.
The manager and staff went above and beyond to help make a very special evening for my family. I can’t thank them enough. Kids menu, creation of extra dish for my son, gluten free menu, specially prepared gluten and dairy free dessert off menu, delicious food, selection of table day before with private room and fireplace, chilling bottle of sparkling cider to go with an excellent bottle of champagne, and assistance with pictures to make a wonderful marriage proposal. Thanks again!!!
This place was amazing! The cozy atmosphere paired well with the delicious cuts of meat and live jazz accompanying our meal. We celebrated the birthday of my wife and her twin brother, both of which really enjoy steak, and no one was disappointed. Along with our perfectly cooked to order steaks, we got an assortment of sides and everything was wonderful. Wed made a reservation for the event and the table was waiting for us when we arrived. The staff was very kinda and attentive and made it a point to make sure the celebration was special. I could go on at lengths about this place but suffice it to say it was an excellent experience and we will certainly be back.
Booked a table on sat 2/13 for a nice valentines dinner. I wish we had picked a different place. I ordered a med cooked filet and received a well done steak. My waitress knew the people at the next table, and continued to carry a conversation with them for nearly 10 minutes instead of checking on us. I had my steak pushed to the side and wasnt eating, waiting on her to finish up her talk with her friends. They were her friends, I heard all about their hobbies, kids and the waitresses husband. Very unprofessional. The worst part is she glanced over several times and ignored me and that fact that my plate was pushed to the side. When she finally came to our table my fiance was finishing up with his ribeye. The manager came by and offered to take the steak off of my check and someone from the kitchen told us that dessert was on the house. I thought that was really great that they were going to do that, since our meal together was ruined. We ordered red velvet cake, which taste like it had been sitting in a refrigerator uncovered. The cheesecake with the black cherry sauce was really good. When the bill came, we were charged for the steak. The steak that I had took 2 bites out of, bc I wanted to continue my meal and just have dessert with my date. Also, our 2 hr time limit on the table was almost up. We didnt bother to complain about it, we were already feeling uncomfortable bc we had to send back a filet in a quality steakhouse. I chose this Hyde Park bc this is the one I started coming to over 20 yrs ago, and remembered it being small and romantic. I wish I had chose one closer to home, bc this experience was so bad I dont think I will ever eat at Hyde Park again.
How does one begin to describe the utter decadence of such perfection in cooking. As I write this I am still purring with total and complete bliss. The NY Strip with mushrooms and garlic was easily the most incredible steak Ive had the joy and pleasure of eating. Cooked to a delicious rare with a dark red center that was incredibly melt in your mouth Joy. Mmmmm. Perfection. The wide cut lamb chops melted in our mouths with a sauce that is quite incomparable to anything else Ive ever had the pleasure of tasting. The lobster Mac n cheese was a gift from the gods. The Brussel sprouts were unbelievably flavourful and so delicious that I would have asked for more if I werent burning full from the rest of our meal. But truly the crowning grace and glory of our night was dessert. The Red Velvet cake was rich, smooth, and so incredibly melt in your mouth perfection that I almost cried for want of another bite. And then there was the New York Cheese Cake with its intoxicatingly sweet sauce... I have truly died and found paradise in food form. Thank you for the most exquisite dinner!!!
So amazing, food was delicious and service was spectacular!
I came here for my belated birthday celebration last night. We were seated in the back when a very loud anniversary part came in. The waitress was so gracious in moving us to a different table that was quieter. We were impressed with everything from thr service, the food, and the drinks. I had the steak griffin, the steak was like butter and the sauce was amazing. Their pretzel bread sticks are also fabulous. We shared the brussel sprouts and potatoes gratin between 3 if us, they were amazing and we still had enough to take home for leftovers. For $1.95 you can add their house salad, my mom was expecting it to be a tiny plate of greens with dressing but it was the same size as my caeser salad that was $9 and it was nice mix of greens and toppings. They jumbo sea scallops with lemon sauce that was the special for the night were also amazing. Every person who interacted with us said happy birthday to me and they gave me a complimentary dessert. The whole experience was perfect!! 10/10 highly recommend for special occasions.
A fantastic evening. We celebrated our 48th anniversary and the choice of restaurants could not have been better. From the hostess to the manager to our waiter we were made to feel special. The food was delicious and if anything we ate a little too much. We never got the feeling that the waiter was trying to turn the table. The waiter can make a good meal- great.
We went there for the first time and were very happy that we went early (5:00 pm). The bar was hopping and it was already pretty full. Parking when we left was totally full. The service was great and our waiter was friendly but professional. The noise level from the bar was a bit high but the ambience of the room where we are seated was very nice, with a cozy fireplace in the corner. Plan to spend quite a bit for your dinner entree. It was an a la carte menu, and the cost of side dishes is high. Our fish selections were cooked very nicely and the side salad included a good selection of vegetables. Overall, it was an enjoyable experience.
Oh my gosh the waitress should have just sat down and dined with us. She was on it!!! We wanted for nothing! The food fawsome. For those of you who dont know what that is....FABIOUSLY AWESOME!! I had the surf and turf,both worlds ya know??? It was so so good. The steak was so tender cooked EXACT and the lobster well it was lobster with melted butter, need i say more??? Generous portions. What an experience!!
I took my wife to the Upper Arlington location and originally had a reservation for 6:15pm, but we discovered that we would be free much sooner, so we bumped our reservation up to 4:45pm. This was our first visit to any Hyde Park location, for our first anniversary, no less, and Im very happy this is what i decided on.We were welcomed promptly and escorted to our table where our server Greg poured our water and introduced himself. We were one of his first tables for the night, so it was still very peaceful in the section. Throughout the evening, Greg proved to be a great entertainer, guide through the menu, and overall joy to have serving us.My wife ordered the steak Tressel,14 oz strip with mushrooms and garlic cloves, cooked a little less than medium-rare, or rare push as Greg recommended. I ordered the steak Herbstreit, a 22 oz bone in ribeye, medium rare. We ordered a caesar salad, sautéed spinach and mushrooms, and garlic whipped mashed potatoes. The steaks were perfect and beyond description and all of the add-ons were very good. Greg and Desiree did a fantastic job, and i will definitely return to this location in the future. You will pay more here than if you go to some of the very commercial chains, but the experience and attention to every detail are worth it. Job medium-rare(well done) team!!
Dined there to celebrate my sons birthday. There were 5 of us on a Saturday evening. We had been here multiple times earlier in life and wanted to treat my son to a wonderful birthday dinner. I checked reviews and this location had the best so we decided to try it again. We arrived early for a 6 pm reservation and had difficulty finding a parking space in a small, dimly lit lot. We were seated promptly. Given the price of the meals and the appearance of wait staff we would have expected superior service. It was slow and we were not certain if it was due to kitchen or service staff. Drinks were superb, shrimp cocktails too but the rest of the meal we felt was average at best. All high grade-steak purchases. Some steaks were actually tough. The Kosar topping was good. We did gave a great chance to visit but the timing between water, drinks, apps, entree and dessert was slow and frustrating. We could have predicted this when we walked past the kitchen to be seated and the service staff were lined up at the counter. They handed us a card to celebrate the birthday but that was all. We have been to other establishments that offer free desserts to share. It may have been a bad night for them but expensive for us. We did receive a voicemail to review our experience but did not call back. Too expensive and too many great choices to give this location another try.
We just had a lovely meal with great service and wonderful food. We were celebrating my birthday and our 33rd wedding anniversary and the staff had decorated our table with rose petals and a card. As usual, the food was perfect and the staff was very attentive and excellent. This continues to be our “go-to”. Place for special occasions and when we want a great steak.
Ive been coming to this location since the late 2000s. Before that, we use to dine at the Crosswoods location before it closed. I have NEVER had poor service and never waited for a table since we always make a reservation. Over the years, weve come to Greg as OUR server. He is always so warm and welcoming and I always request him.On my most recent experience, while dining with my boys on Dec 23rd, dinner was on point, as usual. My son (13), who has a very adventurous and some times uneducated appetite, ordered a Shrimp Cocktail. He loves Shrimp and just assumed hed like this. He didnt realize it was served cold. Greg was kind enough to remove it from our table without shaming my son and also removed it from our bill. I wouldnt have minded paying for something, unbeknownst to me, he hadnt had before. Our entrees all arrived at the same time and my steak was perfectly grilled to Medium Rare Push with a side of Bearnaise *YUM* The Scalloped Potatoes are to be shared, but I kindly warned my boys that this is for momma.When it was time to pay, my card was declined!!! Turns out, my card was compromised, and I was COMPLETELY embarrassed not to have another form of payment. Considering Greg has come to know me over the years, he reassured me not to worry and went to get the manager. The manager was also very reassuring and gave me his card and said to give him a call once it was worked out. For a place to be so understanding, especially when the bill is over $200, is amazing to me. I love this place for their kind service, amazing food, and fun atmosphere.
Great atmosphere. Top notch service. The steak i had was not carefully selected. It had to much gristle for a porterhouse steak. I t was properly cooked however. The lobster bisque was fantastic. The spinach and mushrooms were overly salted, absolutely no need for sea salt. The dish wasnt creative. It was simply sauteed. The cheesecake tasted packaged but the cherry sauce was divine.
Their bone-in fillet is as good a steak if not better than any Ive tried. Service is impeccable and the atmosphere at all locations is outstanding. I particularly like the Henderson Rd. location because it is the most romantic atmosphere in my opinion. The downtown location is very hip and modern. I have never regretted a trip to Hyde Park.
Went to this place after hearing decent things about the other locations. As we went in having reservations @ 6:45 waited until about 8:15 to speak to the manager. He came out and had nothing to say but sorry and theyll have the food out soon. we talked to a couple sitting at the table by us saying wine was better than food after 30 minutes of more waiting we ended up leaving. we waited 2 hours for drinks and bred. Horrible experience wouldnt recommend this place and will never be back!
Atmosphere was good, wait staff was excellent, drinks and sides were fine(including trying escargot for the first time). But the actual steak itself was nothing to write home about. I was expecting a bit more from a $41 bone-in ribeye. It was undercooked slightly and did not have the flavor I was hoping for. I should be fair in saying that I thoroughly enjoy grilling at home on my charcoal or cast iron, so my idea of a great steak might be higher than some others. I guess my review comes down to the price... I feel that I could have bought and grilled a much better steak myself for less.Update: The manager personally reached out to me to discuss what they could have done better and how to improve in the future. I thought this was very professional and I appreciated the willingness to improve. My wife and I will definitely be back for dinner in the future.
Our service was impeccable, Olivias timing was perfect! We waited for nothing and the food was amazing. Steaks were cooked to perfection and everything we ordered was mouthwatering! Definitely worth the hour drive! Well be back!
My husband and I come to Hyde Park every year to celebrate our anniversary and birthdays. Last night we went there to celebrate my husband’s birthday. When we go there we always order the 12 oz rib-eye and last night both of our steaks had a large amount of fat in them. We expect marbling and enjoy it throughout the steak but last night most of our steaks were fat. This was also the first time we weren’t offered a complimentary dessert when celebrating a birthday. On a positive note, the sides were delicious as they always are. We also sat close to the band, which we really enjoyed and we were thankful we were given that option.
Very busy food was great ! Love the wedge salad!
Came here with my family last night to celebrate my graduation. We had to wait an hour before they even brought our drinks. Finally ordered, and waited another hour and a half for food that never came. The couple at the table next to us also complained saying the wine was better than their food. We all got up & walked out. Horrible experience. Would not recommend. And won’t be back. Not to mention we had reservations.
This was my first time there for dinner, and the food was incredible! The service was also excellent, although I would have thought that when we left amd I said have a good night to the two gentlemen at the host/hostess stand, that I would have at least received maybe a look in the eye or a heartfelt reply, instead of the snooty silence of indifference that I got from the one gentleman in the white coat?
Fortunately, Ive never spent my own money here (always been treated for family events). The steaks are good, but in the 2 times Ive been there they havent gotten my order right. The first time, I ordered my steak medium and it came out almost alive. The second time, I ordered a steak with one of their signature sauces on it and it came out without it. Ill be passing on further invites here. Poor attention to detail.
Went with a small group for a retirement party. Several in our party had to send steaks back. Mine was basically raw, sent it back, still not right. One of the family style sides arrived after most were finished eating. As this was on the company, I sincerely hope that our group experience was reflected on the bill. Not being a fan of valet parking, that was the only option that night. Usually not a deal breaker for most I suppose. Very disappointed. Have been to the Frantz Rd location several times and everything is always spot on. Will not do the Old Henderson location again.
Great atmosphere in this high end steakhouse. Wine great, service great, bread and side items great. Steak frankly was only average. Of a quality I would expect at a chain style place. I asked for medium rare with a push, steak was way past that, I would say medium with a push, and the cut was not as good as I would have expected for the price we paid.
Always great service. Food is consistantly wonderful, old steakhouse charm decor
Great atmosphere and even better service. Staff was on top of everything and genuinely engaging. The steaks for our dinner were cooked to perfection. The only thing I would change would be the free valet parking as the parking lot is small to begin with and I would rather not have others drive my car.
Ive been here three times, and I only had good food one of the three times. The wedge salad is fantastic, the steaks are above average, although they seem to have issues with hitting a perfect medium rare. Most recently, I ordered a burger medium, and it was totally dry, cooked past well-done. The lobster mac and cheese, while very flavorful, has trace amounts of lobster, and is not really cheesy the way I like mac and cheese; rather it is more like pasta in a cream sauce. I probably would not order it again. The fries and onion straws have both been solid each time Ive gone. They do have a good selection of wines to go along with the meats.Service is very cordial. You get greeted at the door, at the host stand, and servers are attentive with drinks.
Atmosphere was wonderful but they got both orders wrong has to get it redone. Wine was paired perfect. It really is a good place. I would just have second thoughts about spending anymore of my own hard earned money maybe the next time family comes
Service and atmosphere was excellent. Kansas city bone in steak cooked medium rare was one of the toughest steak I have ever ordered. If it wasnt for my company, I would have sent it back to the kitchen. Took it home, tried it again the next day. No better. Down the garbage disposal it went.
An excellent steak and great service are features of this fine eatery. We were seated promptly, treated with care, and happy with everything. But the live band wasnt there. Valet parking was self-park, which works great for me.
No Calamari and the bartender treated me an my 2 friends not so good. He was not attentive, did not clear out plates timelt and waiting until all of his other customers left, i mean paid bills and all before he once again acknowledged us. Sad part is, we are black n so was he. We all noticed the start difference in how he treated us verses them. This we always expect from OUR people. I live in walking distance to this location and thought this would be my new hangout. Sadly, since i love Hyde Park everything an all locations (except my first visit and last at this location) i now drive 4 miles or so to Dublin. They treat me well.
Excellent service and the steaks, as always, was perfect. The original Columbus Hyde Park in Upper Arlington is romantic and always a great place to take a date. I had filet and lobster tail this trip and could not have been more please. My date cant stop thanking me.
Have been here multiple times in the past with great experiences. On 12/14 we had a party of 8 with a group of friends for a Christmas get-together. Service was downright awful. First round of drinks took over 10 minutes to get to the table, had to chase the waiter to keep our drinks full, had to ask for menus after sitting for 20 minutes, leftovers got swept away without offering to box them, ignored our table when we didnt want to order deserts, split the checks in the wrong way and then got annoyed when we asked to fix it.disappointed in a place we could always count on for great service.Regards,Justin
Classic steakhouse worth a visit. This location is quieter and more intimate, something I really value. Service and food are well above average, with real passion for good food and service. The well-stocked bar offers delicious and imaginative cocktails. Visit the bar side during happy hour for outstanding food and drink bargains.
My steak was cooked to perfection and our culinary experience was one I will never forget. Best meal Ive had in a long time. I might even have to say its better than my grandmothers cooking. Dont tell her I said that..
Wow! We enjoyed the food, the atmosphere, the drinks, but we will return because of the service!!! Greg and Tim both took fantastic care of us and are so warm and welcoming! Thank you for a fantastic evening!
Just a phenomenal experience tonight for my fathers bday. This is his favorite restaurant in Columbus (Henderson Rd. location) and they did not disappoint. Very attentive and kind server (I think named Craig) and the food was on point even more than usual. I often get slightly let down when getting a wagyu or filet elsewhere but the 12 oz. Steak Kosar I had tonight was perhaps the best steak Ive ever had (definitely among the best) and more affordable than some of the other high end steak offerings in the city!
My husband and I love coming here on a Friday evening, Dave Powers plays the piano and sings and the people, food and service is excellent! Worth a five star. AND my husband planned my Surprise Birthday party for me on June the 17th this year 2017. I had a BLAST! 😘
From the king crab appetizer to the waygu filet and raspberry sorbets everything was amazing and prepared to perfection! The service was attentive but not pushy and the atmosphere was comfortable. We super enjoyed our first visit to Hyde Park and will definitely return!
Food and service were both spectacular.
Easter Sunday was absolutely made amazing by the service as our Server and staff really made it happen!! The food was out of this world😁The atmosphere brought me back to my childhood ...My Italian father and his friends. Love Love Love and Love!
Service was commendable. Under cooked steak was disappointing but did have a good flavor. Brussel sprouts were delish! Creme brulee was not creamy enough... Almost gelatinous. Overall I expected more for paying $215 after tip
So good! Best steak I have had in some time.
Service was very, very good. I was disappointed with my filet. It was butterflied and because of this lost it juices. Also there was quite a bit of sinew in the meat. My husbands dish was prepared properly but he didnt care for it but that was no fault of the restaurant.
By far our favorite steakhouse in Columbus and Cleveland. The food quality is everything you would hope it would be at that price point. The customer service is second to none. My only regret is that we don’t eat their more often and that the Worthington location is closed.
The Bergdoll clan love this dining spot. Cozy and always so welcoming. Adam drives greatness- he greets you at the door and you will find him delivering delicious fare at the table in concert w waiters. Managing a great experience w a welcoming smile. Waiters are more than accommodating and constantly striving for perfect service.I havent mentioned the food to this point- because, I assume that you know that they have totally nailed it for decades. Perfect steaks and fish dishes meet your expectations. Just a classic steakhouse that makes you feel at home.Highly recommend. Adam will be at the door to greet you.M Todd Bergdoll.
10 star restaurant with excellent cuisine and top notch service. Reservations highly recommended
The food was not worth the $$, but it was still good! Service was great. It was very loud inside though, my husband and I couldnt even hear each other across the table.
Valet spots are blocked off right in front when the parking lot is 40 yards max in every direction, is valet really necessary; oh wait it is since valet has blocked off the the close spots. Yes, it is free but now $3 tip for allowing to park 20 ft away. Our service was sad, my wife sympathized and said you never know what the waiter is going through but is was sad; we had to steel silverware from the next empty table since we did not get any and food was getting cold , forgot 2 parts of the order/ or perhaps kitchen did screw up?, had to steel my water from my wife since few refills apparently. Food was off: soup was lukewarm, asparagus was drowned in olive oil, molten cake was over baked and not flavorful (just went to Barcelona, with stuffy nose, and had theirs and still it tasted better). We had 1 side, 3 apps and 1 dessert, 3 drinks did not help, and bill was 87. Oh, wine by glass selection had favorites, I looked up on phone the fav was given an 85. Ordered 18 a glass that was good but not that good to be the most price glass. Wine must have very high markup and I understand markup is usually double retail.
Excellent service and excellent food. We celebrated our daughters 22nd birthday and were treated like royalty. Tim, our waiter was especially kind and attentive!
Absolutely excellent dinner and service. This is one of the very best restaurants in Columbus. Check it out!!
The atmosphere was great. We went there for dinner and we could hear the live music from where we sat. It was a very tranquil feeling and the food was great. I was told it was expensive to eat there. I dont think so, no different from any other good restaurant.
Hyde Park NEVER disappoints! I dont get here near enough, but cherish the times that I do get to spend here with family. Great food and out if this world service (Tim) makes Hyde Park the best steakhouse in Columbus to me.
I brought my fiance to hyde park on the recommendation of a friend. I was absolutely blown away by the service, and the quality of the food. I called in for reservations, and the very polite hostess asked if I was celebrating anything. I casually mentioned that it was my fiances birthday. When we pulled up we were greeted by a wonderful valet, free of charge, (had I known, I would have washed the car,) we were then escorted inside by the hostess. I told her of our reservations and she immediately offered a hearty Happy birthday! and showed us to our table. We ordered wine and shrimp cocktail while we perused the vast menu. Everything was well described and mouth-wateringly tantalizing. We each chose a cut of meat and a side. I chose the wedge salad, and I must say that it was one of the finest salads I have ever had. One of the specials was Lobster Macaroni and Cheese. She chose this as her side, and the waiter remarked that this side, by itself, was worth the trip to the restaurant. Let me assure you, he was a straight shooter. This was exceedingly delicious. I havent even mentioned the steaks! We both had them Tressel Style, with cloves of garlic and sauteed mushrooms. Outstanding. After all of this, our waiter brought over a very large slice of chocolate cake with a solitary candle on top. He said, this is for the birthday girl, and if you dont like chocolate, I would be happy to fetch anything else from our dessert menu. Suffice to say, the cake was beyond expectations. Even more astounding was the fact that it was not reflected on the bill. In summation, I dont have the kind of money it takes to eat here weekly, but if I did, rest assured, I would dine here as often as fiscally possible. I plan to request a trip to Hyde Park for my next celebratory outing.
Amazing food! Kevin the bartender was above board with amazing service and knowledge.
Food was excellent. Service had some hiccups but nothing horribly unexcusable. Would definitely go back.
Had a GREAT early Valentines dinner on Sat. Service was 1st class & the food was wonderful!
Went for happy hour with my husband for some time alone. It was very crowded at the bar but we managed to find a seat. Food was good of course but I will find a little quieter place next time.
Very nice restaurant, with helpful and super friendly staff!The food selections are well portioned & tasty! Totally worth the price! I will be visiting again!
I have been here several times and have always thoroughly enjoyed my experiences. The 1st time I ever went the chef gave us complimentary lamb to try. They really went all out, sold us and we have been back several times. Worth every penny.
Awesome food & service. Its pricey but well worth it. Great place for special occasions or just to stop in for a drink at their fully stocked bar.
Had me birthday dinner here and the service, food and atmosphere was exactly what it needed to be to make this day special!
I have never before I had a bad experience at this restaurant but tonight our steak was very very salty and it was my bad for not sending it back but we were really hungry but I will return again
Amazing steak. I ordered the 14 oz NY strip Tressel steak and I would order again. The asparagus and potato sides were also very good.
We go for happy hour (its till 6:30). The sliders and white pear martini are my favorites. The staff is always friendly.
Perfection as always. Food, service, presentation.
Excellent happy hr - drinks and appetizers .Very friendly and professional staff. Top notch svc.Perfect place for Covid get away.
Our favorite restaurant! The food is fantastic; the service is excellent & the atmosphere is homey. Looking forward to our next visit.
Its not a meal, its an experience! If steak is your preference and served in a unique setting this is the place to go. Every part of our meal was top notch.
The food was delicious and our waiter Jamul was the best! The food is always good there.
Traditional steaks some seafood and chops. Great cocktail and wine list. Steaks are high quality but you pay for it.
Me and my 3 best buddies have a tradition every Valentines to take our wives out for a special dinner, we essentially do our best to make it special...we make the reservations, find sitters for the kids..its a big deal!...at any rate for the 2014 Valentines, I called on 1/30/14 and reserved for a table for 8 in the jazz lounge for dinner at 7pm on 2/15/14, matter of fact I called twice that day just to make sure I have a table in the jazz lounge, they did mention they may not have a table big enough for 8 so I suggested 2 separate reservations one for 6 and another 2, which they did agree to. I got a call on 2/13/14 at 3.14pm confirming my reservation. On the material day (2/15/14) we arrived all set for a wonderful experience only for them to check their list and tell me they did not have my name or number in their reservation list. Well, I pulled my phone and showed them the log for the incoming call I received 2 days prior, they looked at the number and told me that it is not their number, which obviously made me look like a liar....I decided to dial the number right there and then and guess what? the phone right behind the check in counter rings, they pick it and and proceed to answer and I go..thats you answering my call! ......... The thing that annoyed me the most was the gentleman (I assume he is/was the manager, but did not identify himself as such) seemed quite unapologetic, just repeating that they have prepared a table for us in the main dinning area and we can have it if we want it...we ended up taking the table because we were determined to have a good evening.... but you can be sure we will neither be going back there nor recommending this restaurant to anyone...Just to be fair the lady who sat us was really wonderful and apologized profusely for the mess and did a great job trying to defuse the situation...the servers were also wonderful and so was the Valet.
Best steak ever! Great staff! Greg our server was pretty awesome too.
Best filet mignon and lobster Ive ever had.
Lovely evening. Food as delicious as always! Service excellent. Joe was our server. Very attentive.
A great meal as always, the filet was cooked perfectly and the sides were, we had the brussel sprouts and the creamed corn, were phenomenal.
Each year we have our year end Board meeting at this location. Food is excellent. Service is top notch! Thank you Greg!!
My boyfriend and I went tonight. The best food and service in Columbus! The yellow fin Tuna was mind blowing! I cant wait to go back.
Took my wife there on her birthday. Both of the steaks were a little chewy as was the shrimp cocktail.Service was good.
Great place! Its what I would expect for a higher end steak house. Staff was friendly and food delicious.
We simply love this location. The food is amazing, the manager, Adam, is amazing, bartender Jennifer is amazing, and Greg the waiter is amazing. I cant say it enough!
Lovely service and the food is delicious. The escargot was such a treat and the old fashioned was one of the best Ive had.
Great food and atmosphere but we felt cramped and people walking by kept bumping into one of our friends chairs-she was annoyed.
Nice atmosphere for a romantic dinner or a holiday party, which is what my company did. Great selection of food, steak was awesome.
Incredible service, amazing food and drinks, and the price point is exactly what it should be for a restaurant of this caliber. Excellent vegetarian/pescetarian options too!
Great experience here. Food and service was beyond excellent! This location trumps downtown 100%
Very good stakes. Dont trust their music events, though. The floor plan probably doesnt let you even see the performer, nor listen to it.
This is my favorite food. I love it. My service was not great the last visit but the food is so fantastic that it made up for it.
Service superior. Food prepared to perfection. Loved the ambiance! Perfect for any celebration.
Phenomenal service, and the food is even better. The best meal youll eat all year.
A truly elegant dining experience! Great food, wonderful staff and good ambiance! Expensive but worth the price.
One of the classic steak houses in Columbus. Always fantastic. Quiet atmosphere. Everything you would expect from a top notch place.
I wish I could eat here every night. Yes, it is that wonderful. From the quality of service to the delicious food.
Amazing dining experience cant wait to go back.
Outstanding steaks and service. Great ambiance. Higher end, a classy place for special occasions.
Expensive, but excellent service and worth the money.
The Best Steak House in Columbus didnt disappoint during our familys Birthday Celebration!
Food was so delish. there was quick and friendly service. the bill was decent.
Dave Powers in the bar -- loved the real jazzWait staff outstandingAnd the food -- picky eaters you are safe, there are many delicious things.
Enjoyed wonderful dinner with friends. Waiter was fantastic and food and drinks superb!!
Every single bite awesome and very SATISFYING. Drinks perfect. Service outstanding!
Food was delicious. Ambiance was cozy and quiet. Went there for a seminar and was pleasantly surprised.
Excellent food and service. They even had rose petals and a card for us for our anniversary!
Food was delicious and service was fantastic!
Whatever the new coating is on the Ribeye, its awful!! cant even taste the steak!
Pricey, but one of the best meals and experiences that weve had in a long time.
Excellent atmosphere, food, and service. Wonderful dining experience. Great staff.
Had a great time for my wifes birthday. Food was excellent. thanks
The food here is absolutely amazing. Best of the best. Pricey, but for good reason.
Words can not express the level of service or the how good the food was
Very intimate atmosphere. Great service food excellent taste presentation and quality.
Seafood tower - fresh. French onion soup that tastes the way it should. Porterhouse steaks...cooked perfect.
Best atmosphere! Key lime pie was a refreshing end to a perfect meal.
Great food, great service, poor rest rooms for those of us with disabilities. Have they not heard of the Americans wìth Disabilities Act?
Excellent food, extremely attentive staff and a nice relaxing experience
Great food and atmosphere.Love going here for dinner.
The food is the best and tell my dad i said hi his name is antwaun he is a chef
Great atmosphere... Very attentive as soon as I walked in and through out the eve ..
Old style steak house. Au gratin and chocolate cloudless torte are outstanding
Always a great choice for all you important dates and celebrations.
Hyde park is a COLUMBUS classic that never lets you down. The steaks are the reason you go but don’t forget the Brussels sprouts or corn.
Excellent food and service. Friday night jazz piano is on point.
A nice classy restaurant with excellent food...also enjoyed the piano singer
Steak Kozar is DELICIOUS! Share a wedge salad for a great dinner
Amazing dining experience!
Great service by Colin!
Delicious!!! Food was perfect, atmospheres was relaxing. Great place!
Incredible atmosphere, staff, and food. It is always a distinct pleasure!
Great food, good staff. Always great experience
Many people like it, I havent been there.
The food was great, their were great cooks. Enjoyed
Delicious food!
A very good meal with many options on the menu for non carnivores
The food was good. The customer service was outstanding!
Great Food - Top Notch Service
What can I say? Great food, good service, lots of love!
Wonderful food, service, and atmosphere ❤
We love to stop at the bar for the Hyde Park Manhattan. Food is great too!
A great place to eat, whether at the bar or for a upscale meal.
Good food but air conditioning not working so good.
This place is 🔥 the food is top notch they need 10 stars
Some of the best steak Ive ever eaten in my life.
My favorite of the Hyde Park restaurants. Its very intimate, and great staff.
High end food and such. Poor service. There are better in this metropolitan area.
Its Hyde Park. Not much else to say. Perfect meal with professional service.
Great service and tomahawk steak was great
Best steak ever...Filet mignon with blue cheese.
Went here for a seminar, their steaks dont live up to all the hype.
Excellent restaurant very expensive, but they have a good early bird special.
Great steak and great sides! Wonderful service.
Very sophisticated place to have a memorable meal.
Once again, Hyde Park has proved itself the best steak in central Ohio.
Excellent steak and sides- great service!!
Its now my 2nd favorite steakhouse in Columbus.
Sad and disappointed with the (lack of) care on the cooking of the meatThey tried to make it right, but the effort fell flat
Total reviews rating 4.7
199 Reviews for Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse 2023:
Review №1
2022-04-24The very best in town. Food, service & atmosphere. The Rahal Ribeye with gratin potatoes is spectacular. Great wine and drink selections. Hands down its the best Columbus has to offer. A must try!
Review №2
2022-06-24Last minute decision for dinner and first time dining here. Outstanding service and wonderful dinner. We can see why they come up the best steak in Columbus. And even celebrated our birthdays!
Review №3
2022-03-25My husband and I went for the first time on Thursday and it was a phenomenal experience. I got the filet and it was cooked perfectly. Everything we ate was amazing, including their $1.95 house salad! We also received complimentary shrimp cocktail for a basically non-existent “wait” on our steaks, which was incredibly thoughtful and much appreciated. Our server was so friendly and really went above and beyond for us for our first visit. We will definitely be back!
Review №4
2021-07-19Weve been to Hyde Park dozens of times, but the service we received for our anniversary dinner this weekend was out of the park good. They really went out of their way to make our night special. The food was excellent as always, though my Mrs. thought her strip steak was just a bit tough. My fillet was awesome as was everything else. Thank you to the manager Phil and our great server and the staff for making our anniversary meal one we wont soon forget!
Review №5
2022-01-24One of our favorite hideaways. Perfect steakhouse ambiance with exceptional service. The filet is always on par, but the cosmos and oysters are out of this world!
Review №6
2022-01-26This was our second time in 14 years. I hate to say but too pricey for us. You have to buy all the extras. I had a salmon salad. It was good but nothing extra special. My husband had a steak. His was good but not great. He loved the mashed potatoes! Brussel sprouts were awesome! Our server was very sweet.
Review №7
2022-02-14Food was great, service was NOT. My date and I had some waiter that seemed like a drunk. He was so rude! To our table and the other tables he was serving! Everyone was talking about it every time he left. We were in disbelief by how much we’re paying for such bad service. I told the manager and he seemed so nonchalant about it. I felt like I was at outback steak house. They were also playing retail pop music?? Sticking to the downtown Hyde Park location! After I told the nonchalant manager, he did switch my waiter to Collin and Collin is Amazing! He apologized and acted way more caring than the manager. He needs to be working at the downtown restaurant. Period.
Review №8
2022-04-03Absolutely delicious! Our waiter Colin was amazing! Everything was cooked perfectly and the dessert was out of this world! 10/10 recommend.
Review №9
2021-06-10Fantastic experience.Went there for my 40th birthday. It will be easy to remember it.Great food. Literally one of only 2 high-end places in Columbus that has managed to get a medium-rare filet mignon right.From the oysters to the bisque to the side dishes: nothing we tried disappointed.The mixed drinks were good and went well with the meal.Staff was great. Ambiance was spot on.👌
Review №10
2022-06-18Went to Hyde Park for my best friends engagement dinner and everything was phenomenal. Our server, Collin, did an excellent job and made sure everything was perfect. Will definitely be back!