Outdoor seating
Yes
Bennys Pizza in Marysville
Categories
Location on the map
Marysville, Union County, Ohio, US
Service options
Kerbside pickup
Yes
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Delivery
No
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Live music
Yes
Popular for
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Kids' menu
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Quick bite
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Lunch
Yes
Dinner
Yes
Catering
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
Good for kids
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
Tourists
Yes
University students
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Payments
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 937-303-8800
Site: http://www.bennyspizza.com/
Site: http://www.bennyspizza.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:11AM–10PM
- Tuesday:11AM–10PM
- Wednesday:11AM–10PM
- Thursday:11AM–10PM
- Friday:11AM–12AM
- Saturday:11AM–12AM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (199)
This place seems really sloppy. So I walked in so I could wait to be seated. Where they had me wait was right in the way of everything, when they found a table it was under the tent where they had several softball teams lots of small children screaming and having fun. Kids will be kids I understand. I seen lots of tables inside so I asked to be moved and they did move us. As for the menu it was really hard to pick something I just prefer buckeye family
The old world pepperoni pizza is so good and their house root beer is AMAZING. My server Katherine was so friendly, knowledgeable and just a good person. Would definitely come back
Great food, great atmosphere, friendly employees!My only complaint is the karaoke dj. Hes terrible! He sits all night and repeatedly misses people in the rotation. Not just by one or two positions in the order but by 5, 6, 7 positions.
I absolutely love going to Bennys anytime I am in Marysville! Their BLT Pizza is my absolute favorite! The servers are always really nice and attentive. My cup has never gone empty here.
Bennys has the best pizza around! I havent had anything bad from there yet! Servers are friendly and helpful and the atmosphere is awesome! Never disappointed!!
Excellent service, well staffed, very good pizza, watching the band on a Saturday night, drove a little over an hour to get here with some friends. Well worth the drive.
I really like their patio and service. Make sure you eat the pizza while its fresh because it is not good reheated and gave me just a little bit of heartburn. Wont stop me from returning though.
There is a MYSTERY that I will help solve for you at Benny’s. Ever wonder why anyone that can drive JUMPS at the opportunity to “go pick up the pizza at Benny’s”?The answer......FREE soft SELF serve ice cream while you wait for your order. Yes, this is one of few places where people are “early” to get their order and DO NOT COMPLAIN AT ALL ABOUT IT!!You can choose from the sit down restaurant but this rating is only for the pick up building (literally a separate spot).I am not a vegetable type of guy BUT you have to try the all vegetable pizza. Alarmingly amazing. The pies are thin sliced. Incredible tastes from start to finish. This is the ONLY pizza I eat as a left over (yes, sometimes for breakfast) and it DOES reheat VERY well. The traditional pepperoni is a perfectly done pie as well. Have tried about 6 versions and all are super great.So, call in your order for pick up, get there early and become part of the quietly, patiently, happy people with a big smile waiting on their pie with a cone in their hands. Cheers to ice cream and great pizza!!
Weve been here before and always sat inside. This time they sat us outside in an enclosed tent and they were not busy. Wobbly tables and chairs. Food was very good and thats why we keep coming back.
It would be 5 stars but some monster cut the pizza like a real pizza and not the little squares that I have become used to since moving to Ohio.Good food I love the garbage pie but since it was cut like a pie all the toppings fall off, which made this fat guy very sad.
The main reason I ordered was the pizza obviously and it didn’t disappoint 5/5. But the fries weren’t edible by any means. But definitely recommend the pizza
We were visiting a brewery in Marysville and stopped to get some pizza beforehand. Glad we chose this local joint. Pizza was really good - thin crust, lots of sauce and well done bake. Wings could have used a little more sauce but the habanero wings were SPICY like I like them. Service was good during a busy Friday night. They have an interesting layout with the restaurant, patio, and pickup being housed in different buildings. Will definitely return when in the area again!Please “Like” if this review is helpful
Ive only been a couple times, but the food is amazing. The pizza, wings and fries are all top notch and some of the best around. My last visit I tried the Belgian Waffle Grilled Cheese out of curiosity and it was one of the best sandwiches Ive ever eaten. And their beer list is really respectable!There is a lot of seating too - both inside and out on their expansive patio. I havent been in the evenings so I dont know how crowded they get, but Bennys is definitely worth checking out!
Excellent pizza, none better in Ohio!Cauliflower crust is extraordinary, kid argued that is was reqular crust...2 times.
Really good Italian sub and excellent pizza. Its no wonder why this place is a local favorite. The outdoor patio is really cool too.
Occasionally you find a place that just blows your mind... For me, this place was it.Wife and I have been driving around Ohio trying out different local places to eat for a little while now.We got in the car today to come down to Marysville, for no real reason, just to explore. We always eat local when we explore, and she was feeling Italian food, which led us to here.They make all sorts of stuff from scratch, I causing their own root beer, and it all tastes great.I got the dagwood fold over, and she got the linguine with the 3 cheese garlic sauce.... Which we split both with each other.Both dishes were amazing.The staff was super friendly, and the service was great.Finished our meal with a piece of buckeye pie, which to not surprise, was amazing.This is one of those places that you hope lasts forever, because its just too good not too.If youre ever in Marysville, or even within 20 miles of it, Id say go the distance to come try this place out.I look forward to coming back and trying more of the menu.
Absolutely amazing! Did the buffalo chicken dip and pizza, big portions, lots of leftovers and phenomenal taste! Cannot wait to go back and try gyros and subs next time
Best Pizza in Marysville, plus you cant beat the live music and outdoor atmosphere!
Good Pizza, Good Subs, Good Draft & Bottled Beer selection, Good Salads, Good Service at Good Prices. This place is a Marysville Staple. I like my pizza with extra sauce. They serve a bottomless bowl of freshly popped popcorn to every table.
Wait what!! Awesome atmosphere!! Great music and of course the staff its amazing!! Love the place in general I definitely will be back!
Manager was awesome and great service with yummy pizza! The band was awesome too!
Great place, Great Food, Def great music. All around best place to hang out have some food and drinks with friends and family and listen to some great music. The workers are awesome also...
Bennys is our go to place every Friday evening for excellent pizza, wings and cold beverages! Love listening to local live entertainment while hanging out with friends and family!
Was told about Bennys from a friend and I am glad I stopped here. They were really busy due to the dinner rush but our server took care of use by keeping our drinks full. The pizza was amazing. Came out pretty fast and it was hot and fresh. No complaints and will be returning.
Met friends there. We ate lunch and had a great time. Food was great, service a little slow due to staff shortage, but did ok. Will definitely go again. 🚶♂️
This was our 1st time here. We had crab mushroom app. It was excellent. You get a lot of food. We will deffinatly return. Chili dog special was a big plateful.
The Pizza and wings were fantastic! Please note the carry out pickup is the building next-door. Read the signs, and enjoy yourself.
We typically go here every Friday night with a group of people and have great service. However tonight we waited over an hour and ended up leaving.
Great atmosphere, love the patio. They have a lot of music in the summer. Good food and decent selection of beer.
The family and I love Bennys. We have usually dined in and picked up to go once. Weve never had to wait to get seated and the staff has always been exceptional. Other places as you know can be hit or miss sometimes, but out of about a dozen visits so far, theyve been impeccable with courtesy and attentiveness.While we havent branched out beyond their pizza yet (but we will), it has been fresh, hot and flavorful every time. The value is there as well. My only critique if I had one is just that if you sit in the patio area, other groups can get rather loud. But, this is mostly to be expected.Overall, we love us some Bennys!Update 1/26/22 - Weve continued to frequent Bennys and even branched out to other dishes. So far, while we still love their pizza, everything has been great. The Gyro was both large and fresh. Onion rings are also very worth it. Cant complain about anything really.In addition, Erica the Balloon Artist is wonderful. Both of our children adore her and shes very interactive and talented. For those interested in seeing Erica, shes there on Tuesday evenings.
Phenomenal pizza! Im going to have to come back for some of their other dishes.
Pizza was great as usual! Been gone for several years but had to have some Bennys while here!
First timers and definitely NOT disappointed. Food was amazing, service was amazing. Will definitely be back!!
The food and service was great especially on a Saturday night during the busy hours. I brought the whole family there, and we all left satisfied.
Great service , great cheeseburger pizza and onion rings.
Great local pizza place. Full lunch and dinner menu. Indoor and outdoor bars with bands in the summer.
Great pizza , HAVE to try spinach dip !Good service. A bit pricey.
We love Bennys pizza! We had a party of 22 and they took care of our entire party with patience and promptness. Our party ordered old world pepperoni, cheese, and a Hawaiian pizzas. All of the choices wee well liked. Bennys has a cool atmosphere (can be too loud for older folks) lots of outdoor space. Be sure to check the summer concert list and enjoy some live music too! When Im the area, we will definitely go back!
I drive about 30 minutes each way to pick up Bennys Pizza after having multiple friends recommend it to me. They swore to me that its the best pizza theyve ever had but, in my opinion, Bennys is overrated and way too expensive relative to the quality of pizza. The sauce and crust have a distinct flavor that I wasnt vibing with but Im assuming thats what keeps people coming back. Its a local favorite so theyre obviously doing things right and if a friends recommended it to you, I think its definitely worth a try--just not my type.
Quite an unassuming place honestly. I wasn’t sure what to think we we arrived. The inside was cozy and friendly. We decided to take our party outside and was our jaws dropped when we walked out back. The place was massive! Tons of outdoor seating and a large bar area. We ordered a few appetizers and they were all delicious and moved on to the pizza. OMG! The pizza was amazing! We ordered the Smoked BBQ Chicken and the All The Way Pizzas. They were magnificent! Crispy, flavorful crust, plenty of toppings and delicious sauces made these pizzas unique. I’ll be back the next time I’m in Marysville for sure. Cheers!
Food very good service very good, my onion rings were cold. I dont send food back. But all in all great will be back!
Consistently outstanding food. Service has always been attentive and prompt. Excellent value.
530pm on a Friday night. They were busy so we chose to sit at the bar, not a big deal for us. Cannot believe how busy they were! Service was great. Two different managers walked into the bar area at different times, saw different things needed to be done and just did them. Pizza was very good! Thick crust but had a really good crispness to it, not greasy like deep dish.
Wow what a great place! We shared pizza, pasta & a Phili beef. Great portions. Tuesday was create your own pasta! I had a small Cajun red sauce with linguini dine to perfection
Experience w Reaganomics was great! Food was okay.
We had heard great things about their food in the past. We happened to be in Marysville and decided to try it for ourselves for the very 1st time. We were not disappointed. We ordered loaded fries to start and ordered an Italian sun (me) and an pizza fold over (wife). Fantastic food. We also ordered a pizza to go to have for dinner later that night. And the server was excellent as well. We will absolutely be back.
Tried Bennys upon recommendation of a few locals. Didnt feel like pizza, but there are quite a few options on the menu - the BBQ chicken salad was very good! The large salad was likely more than I should have eaten, think Ill go with the small next time around. Apparently this restaurant is usually busy, I happened to catch a Monday that was not - though I sat at the bar, the huge outdoor seating area looked pretty nice. The waitstaff was friendly, and I saw a lot of joking and camaraderie between them, must be a good place to work!
Love the crust! Great pizza and large crowd keeps it fun.
Fantastic pizza toppings and the best crust. Wide variety on menu and the best staff you will find. Best experience is during the summer eating on the patio listening to a live band.
We enjoy the bands playing on the outside stage during the summer weekends!
Food was great. The outdoor patio was a big hit!
The staff are friendly and attentive. 5 stars to them. However, the food is overpriced. 13 dollars for 4 crab and cheese stuffed mushroom is to much in my opinion. It wasnt bad food. Wasnt blow my socks of 13 dollars worth either.
Always a family favorite when we are in Ohio! Wonderful food! They had live music, but it wasnt overpowering so we could still talk. Love the big patio! Nice beer list.
Delicious hot pizza with a thin crispy crust and the service was fast and friendly. Cant go wrong with this place!
Love their pizza! Plenty of beers available too.
Great food..atmosphere, people....staff is excellent....Cody is great
Best pizza and food around! You cant go wrong with Bennys and their homemade root beer!
They have an amazing garbage pizza! Well worth the price. Friendly staff and nice atmosphere.
This place rules! Outdoor bartenders were lazy but pretty chill overall. Highly recommend this place. Top 20 pizzas of my lifetime and that’s not an accreditation that’s handed out lightly.
I really like the atmosphere. The pizza was good as so were the chicken chunks. The food was a little better than average but nothing special. No complaints.
I’m a huge fan of comfort food restaurants, especially pizza and wings! Unfortunately, the pizza is okay and the wings are microwaved frozen nuggets. We gave it a second try with spinach dip, (nasty,) Buffalo chicken dip (very sour) and the pretzels. I love pretzels and the beer dip was pretty good! Third try we had another round of pizza and garlic parm wings.. honestly not going to eat there again. Really wanted to like it so I gave it three chances but hey, at least the pretzels are good. Honestly would not recommend
Disappointed with the spaghetti but their pizza is really good! Our server he was kind
AMAZING pizza! Friendly staff, great service.
Little pricey, however food was perfect and the atmosphere just as good !
Some of the best pizza in the area and neighboring towns.
7 out of 10. The sauce was bland. Either needs to be sweet or tangy. Great service, cold beer, popcorn, and chicken wings. Will come back when in area.
Super tasty. Homemade meatballs were on point. Ask for Denise; she rocked! One of the best waitresses Ive interacted with recently. Give her a raise!
Ordered 4 different pizzas ahead of arrival And they were ready, hot and delicious! We also got a bonus serve ourselves an ice cream cone! Very clean and the service was very polite and efficient!
Best pizza in town and everywhere! They are a little pricy on their pizza compared to retail but it is so worth it. Their employees are always friendly and their service is quick. I got there to pick up my order a few minutes early. While I waited they offered ice cream.
Food is a bit expensive. They dont really have a menu for mixed drinks. One they call sewer water taste like watered down Malibu rum... its missing something flavor wise. Also sometimes it would come in a large cup and sometimes it would come in a small cup? The other one a frost top was decent since it was made with root beer it had flavor. The loaded fries were good. A friend got them first and hers looked kind of over baked so when ordering mine asking them to under bake it they came out perfect. Lastly music is a bit loud. I get its outside and all but its hard to talk to the person next to you even when your leaning over right in their ear.
We went to watch a band play and to have dinner with friends. I was part of a large group there were about 12 of us and we all got to sit together. The food was fantastic. The portions were large and the drinks were good. My bill for myself and husband was over $100 but that was with drinks.
Very good service and food. Would like a bit more variety.
Bennys is definitely the place on Saturday night live band. Gets the place hopping.And the pizza sooo delicious,thin crust and many toppings. The staff is amazing friendly and U dont get thristy. Fun time
Good Food !Quick Service !Excellent Staff !Fun Atmophere !Karaoke Is Awesome !
Excellent pizza and wings! We the best Hawaiian pizza weve ever had here and the homemade bbq sauce on our chicken wings was the bomb! Friendly and fast service topped off our dining experience. We will definitely be heading back for some more in the near future!!
We seen Acoustic Super Friends on Thurs. Probably the best acoustic act Ive seen. The name could be changed to Replica very good entertainers one acoustic and a lead vocalist. The singer sounded like the original singer to the songs the performed. The guitarist was great, knew all processing and the tricks to pull it off and also sang harmony and occasionally lead vocals.
Had a good night here when the crew all went out there for pizza.
Excellent pizza, but the outdoor atmosphere is a real treat w some very entertaining bands.
Great pizza and ice cold beer.
Cool place for music and great thin pizza
The best pizza. BBQ chicken #1 out of all BBQ chicken I’ve tried. Pepperoni is just great, because of the sauce. Can’t go wrong. Just be ready for the carbs.
The staff at Bennys was so incredibly nice without being over the top or seeming fake. Everyone seemed to genuinely care about our experience there! The food was amazing too! The soft pretzel we had as an appetizer was the best wed ever had, and the pizza tasted SO good! Well definitely be back the next time we pass through town!
I’m visiting from Chicago and this is by far the best pizza I’ve had here. Definitely will be getting more before I leave. The cheesecake wasn’t that good though. There isn’t any graham cracker crust on it which is kind of weird and its from Chicago?
Pizza is absolutely delicious, best for miles around. Beer is always cold, great atmosphere and you cant help but have a helluva good time. Bennys rocks!
The pizza is amazing. Fresh ingredients great beer selection and our bartender was fantastic. The outdoor area looked like it was a lot of fun.
If I could give a zero star rating I would.To start off, the table we got when we sat down was so wobbly we were afraid that our drinks would slide off the table. We then asked to be moved to another table and the waitress seemed very angry at that request. After some minutes we were moved outside to a table that still wobbled, not as bad but still. We ordered our drinks and they tasted like straight up syrup. The waitress seemed very impatient and kept coming back every couple minutes asking if we were ready to order. One of the members of our party had a question about the menu and the waitress was very rude in her answer. After some time we were ready to order and we did. After we ordered and our food came the waitress only came around maybe 3 times during the hour we were there.Then when we were paying I gave the waitress cash and told her to break another $20 bill. She kept the change from the bill without my explicit instruction and brought back the broken $20 bill. I then gave her a $15 tip on top of the change I assume she kept.This brings me to what makes me the angriest. I heard through other sources that the waitress claims that I didnt tip her. Assuming that she kept the change, I gave her close to a 44% tip with the $15 I gave her.
That place is amazing. Brian is very friendly and makes sure if my mom stops by she is treated by friendly and helpful staff.Great meatball sub too
Nice place with huge patio. Pizza is very good. Service was outstanding. Recommend a mid-afternoon on Saturday.
Great place. Period! Great service, food and value. I have been there twice now and ordered takeout once. Everything I ordered was prepared perfectly and was a price I felt was appropriate. The patio they have is massive and looks like it would be a lot of fun when there is no pandemic. I cannot think of a single complaint. Well, maybe the small straws in the sodas 😁
One of my favorite places for pizza anywhere.Quality ingredients and a great tasting crust.The spicy garlic wings are killer.Nice atmosphere. They do get busy but they have a lot of seating. Have never waited long to be seated or served.Nice selection of brews.Good rotating entertainment. Highly recommend!
My husband and myself along with our 3 yr old were staying in Marysville overnight during a weekend trip. Pizza is normally a win so we decided to try out something local. This joint was beyond crowded for a Saturday night...cars were parked in the grass. And the band was way too loud. We opted to order pick-up...overall the pizza was a bit overpriced and just eeh. Would not make it a regular stop.
Absolutely best pizza and homemade root beer in the region
A little out of the way from Columbus but well worth the trip. Pizza was great, if not the best Ive had in the area close to it. The sauce is perfect, we ordered a little extra sauce and asked for the crust to be crispy but not burnt. Surprisingly the bar tender said they have a setting for that. Highly recommended.
Dean the waiter was fantastic and all 4 us really enjoyed the delicious food.If you have not eaten there you should try it. You will be impressed.
I love Benny’s. I’ve been eating and hanging out here for a few years now. Last week went for some food and live music. Before we could finish packing up our food to take home, and settle in for music. They came over and said that we need to get up so they can clean the table for a party that just walked in the door and wants to sit by the stage. Dropped our checks off and waited for us to pull out our cards. There where 4 other tables on the patio that party could have been seated at. Like I said I loved Benny’s for years but after that experience it might be a while until I go back if I go back at all. I go there for the atmosphere not the food. The food isn’t that great (for the price they charge) and if that’s all there serving now is food with no atmosphere/good time hang out I won’t be back.
Pizza is top notch! Generous with the toppings.
Excellent food. I had the gyro. It had lots of meat, sauce, vegis, aVegas, very good. My husband had beef stroganoff. He said it was delicious. We both brought left overs home.😊
They kicked me out because they said I was in a fist fight on the 4th of July. I was actually in Arizona celebrating with my family. Their food has gone down really bad. Their service has been horrible lately.
Good food, good service, kind of high price, but you pay for pizza 🍕 thats very good, the big thing is Bennys business is very busy all the time, alot of time you wait for a table
It was a chilly evening to listen but love this band so it was worth the trip. The pizza is great...staff and service was awesome.
Great food. Fast service. Fair prices
Service was great. Pizza excellent, beer cold. What more can you want.
Try to get there at least a couple times per year. Great pizza, subs, and service.
Excellent food. Excellent place to eat. Great service. Very friendly. Kept my glass full. I eat here every time I can.
The staff are energetic and the atmosphere is fun. It is hard to decide what to order with the variety on the menu. I love the outside bar and the huge seats. They swivel and are very comfortable.The spinach dip is my favorite and comes with warm pita bread and chips. Their servings are large which makes it easy to share with others.
The first time I had a Personal Pizza was delicious. This time was not the same. Ordered thin crust got thick crust. The chicken tenders were burned on the end. Onion rings were terrible. Ham on my pizza was partially cooked. Very pricey and will not be returning.
Bought an order of tacos and a Greek pizza 11/18/2020. Let me just say, the pizza was delicious. Tacos were good. However. I ordered online and marked to add chicken, bacon and banana peppers and also no black olives. We got the chicken and no black olives. But we didnt get the bacon or the banana peppers. We drove 15 mins there and 15 mins back, so I wasnt going back to get it fixed. And as I said the pizza was delicious.
Great neighborhood pizza place. Huge. Beer garden with live music attached. Large bar. Plenty of seating. Take out is in same parking lot but in a separate building. Food is good. Good appetizers. Great pizza. Friendly staff. Stiff drinks. Always busy for a reason.
Stopped in on the way to Indian Lake it had been years since I have beenWow you go FredLooks greatPizza is still awesome
Very disappointed with Bennys. I ordered a pizza which was barely warm when got it home (10 min drive) so had to heat it up in toaster oven. Their mushrooms were not fresh (taken from a can) and so disgusting. Definitely overpriced with noticeable decline in quality. I wont return.
Bennys is not as good as it once was.Still pretty good pizza, just not in my top 5 anymore.We ordered a frozen dragon drink, it was not that great. I would recommend, they have a great live music venue.
First visit with family. Great food, quick service for being busy at lunch time on a Saturday, and nice big place! Cool to see all the Reds stuff being from Cincy!
Unique stop, with excellent pizza, wings, and more. Many homemade sauces, creative pizzas with fresh quality toppings set Bennys Pizza apart. Patio, atmosphere, and live music make this an experience all summer.
Fun relaxing atmosphere and the pizza was great. Genuinely a pizza LOADED with toppings. Had a great unfiltered IPA draft, which I forget the name. So good Ill be going back for both. A great option and a short 20 minute drive from the northwest corner of Columbus.
My pizza had excellent flavor but, what Id have to say stole the show was Bennys Belgian Waffles! We tried one and then we ordered ten more to go. Definitely calling ahead the next time through for more. On our visit we found out wed bought all they had made. So good! Kudos...
Pizzas not quite on the mark! I had an all the way; it had very little sauce nor toppings. House salad was lacking crisp lettuce.
Pizza is amazing. Best place to eat in Ohio.
The food is very good. Large outdoor seating area, so social distance is very easy. Staff all wore masks. Salads, pizza and sandwiches are excellent. The price is fantastic.
The only complaint I have about this place was it took too long to actually eat here. Pizza is fantastic I have the smoked Wings which were good and the service was excellent. Five stars across the board. I might edit this once I go and watch some of the Bands they have. Definitely a place to check out. Very impressed.
My best friend who passed away from covid January 2nd and our husbands would away stop at Bennys on our way home from Indian Lake such a nice day we went in her honor and thanks to her we became to love it there and will be back and recommend it to everyone ❤
Great Pizza & fast service. Definitely plan on returning
Very popular with locals. Many people we know drive 35 miles past a lot of pizza places to get to this one. Quality of food and service is always excellent. Prices are a little high , but worth the trip.
Kind of funky atmosphere with lots of families having a good time. Southwest Cobb salad was excellent (I had the eggs left out) the kids had pizza and wings, and we all loved it. Definitely will go back. On Wednesdays they have a balloonartist making things for the kids at the tables-no charge.
Best place to get delicious thin crust pizza in central ohio. The homemade Robins BBQ that they use to put on their BBQ Chicken Salad and BBQ Chicken pizza is the best I have ever had.
Enough room for a large crowd. The live music was good. The pizza was delicious. Lots of toppings.
Tad pricy but worth it, free ice cream if you pickup with kids (2nd machine broken, so you get vanilla or chocolate, no choice)
The service was fantastic! I had a sweet waitress named Jordan who reminded me of my best friend. She checked up on us enough but not enough to be over bearing. The food was also quite good. 10/10 experience.
Wow very impressed with the quality of the food. Everything we got as amazing! As soon as you sit down they give you popcorn. We got the spinach dip with pita bread/chips, 18 pizza half cheese half pep and mushrooms, and 6 sweet chili wings and 6 robin bbq. Hands down absolutely amazing experience. The only improvements I would make is the entrances could have a bigger walk way , and the bathrooms temp was crazy hot like hard to breath hot and you could upgrade the toilet paper ....
What can you say......they have Wonderful Amazing pizza. Besides the regular toppings pizzas, they also have unique specialty pizzas. Highly recommend the BLT pizza, sounds strange, but it is AMAZING!
Big portions reasonably price delicious homemade food
Fantastic pizza and subs. Atmosphere is great. But it is very pricey. You get what you pay for though.
I didnt care for when I assume it was a member of management asked that my 6yr old return to our table. The excuse I was given was basically because of the Governors mandate and something to do with alcohol, which I dont consume anyways when out with my son. But I guess its ok for adults to congregate into a small area and smoke with no social distancing and its not ok for 3 children around the same age to hang out for a few minutes away from everyone else. Nonetheless, we received our order, ate and left. Food was descent, but after said event, I wont return to that establishment for quite sometime, or ever. I dont like that it looked like 3 harmless boys were a target whereas the adults had nothing said to in that case. 👎👎👎
Great time. Thank you for the fun friendly family environment! We attended for the first time for a birthday gathering (30 of us) and had no problems with service and the food was in line with other similar locations that offer live music. The band was fun and engaged the audience well. Bennys Pizza ROCKS!
Unexpectedly disappointed. Outdoor patio dominated by cigar and cigarette smokers. Very intrusive cigar smoke and it felt unsafe amidst expectation of COVID safe dining standards. We have historically loved Benny’s pizza, bar food, cold beer, service and management but the patio cigar & smoking policy will make us choose more pleasant and safe options somewhere else. I really wasn’t looking for a cigarette and cigar bar.
The first time I had the make your own pasta deal the have every tuesday. Beautiful looking home cooked meal with the salad and bread on side. The second time I had a pepperoni pizza with banana peppers. Not my favorite but I look forward in coming back to try the other dishes they have to offer
Love Bennys!! Theyre wings are phenomenal. Probably the best Ive ever had. The smoked flavor makes it! Theyre pizzas great too! They have a huge patio, great for hanging out and having some drinks w/ friends. The staff has always been great, whether it was just a few of us, or a party of 10. Have recommended Bennys to all of my friends.
This was my first time at Bennys and it was a ton of fun. The Cheeseburger Pizza was awesome and the wings were absolutely delicious! The place was packed and there was a live band outside on the patio. Everyone was drinking, dancing, and having an excellent time. If you are looking for a casual place where everyone knows how to have a good time, then I would recommend!
Good food, superb staff. Server gave us complimentary homemade root beer after we asked about it!
Bennys is delicious and they have great root beer. Their popcorn machine is closed until this covid-19 situation is dealt with but they are still 100% awesome!
Pretty good pizza, a little pricey, outstanding service and the entertainment (The Groove) was 2nd to none. Highly recommend Bennys
Bennys is great pizza! Ordered carryout. Was told 40-45 min but probably less. Pizza was ready in 30 min. Not bad for a Saturday evening when they are at their busiest.
There was a mistake made in our order. The restaurant and manager made it right quickly and made an adjustment to the bill without us asking. No one is perfect but the restaurant gave excellent service. It says alot about how they treated us. I would definitely go back. Highly recommend the Texas tacos and the pizza.
Nice menu selection and so-so service, however only YOUR server gives good service, they do not work as a team to ensure comfortable and prompt service, will walk past table full of empty dishes and glasses, sit and talk instead of offer refills or sweep up the messes all over floors. Bartenders also pretty inattentive, sit long durations with empty glasses while they talk to coworkers and their regulars. We now prefer to just order take out, and drink elsewhere
They make the best pizza. Due to COVID-19, havent had the chance to dine in and enjoy the popcorn first.
Incredible selection of high quality toppings for their pizzas. The cheese is excellent and the sauce complementary. I am not a thin crust fan, but I will gladly make this my one exception. The menu is huge, so plan on regular visits. While waiting for your meal, you can take a stroll through the restaurant for a glimpse of their large collection of autographed sport and music memorabilia. They also serve Pepsi products, which is a big plus. For those interested, they are not CCW friendly.
Other than my hometown pizza, this is my favorite pizza. I go with All the Way, their version of a supreme. Its a little messy to eat, but so worth it. They also have a spinach artichoke bread thats heavenly. And you cant forget about the famous pretzel bites and beer cheese. Its indulgent, but so worth every calorie.
Literally the best pizza you will ever have. I moved from Ohio to Arizona quite some time ago, but I come back once to twice a year just to go to Bennys....and maybe to see my family? My husband has never experienced such great service where the waiter treated us like family upon meeting us. I love the fact that they have live music and its a great place to party on the patio. If you arent up to partying, you can sit inside. They have a self serve popcorn maker for while youre waiting for your pizza. I have been coming to Bennys since I was a small child. Their food is so good that they had to open a separate building just for making more pizzas and theyve had several additions to their building to support more guests. Cant say enough good things about this place.
Our server was AMAZING, and the food, EXCELLENT!!!
Pizza is always good. So busy took a while to be served. Worth the wait. Band was good also.
Good food and drink selection. Great thin crust pizza, even if if it is not normally your favorite. it is a little pricer than some pizza places. They are able to attract large crowds when they are allowed.
Ordered food and we are from Marion, got food and my sub was wrong my pie was missing and I paid good money for this!! $7 pie I never got and $12 sub that was nothing but meat no toppings! Waste of my money and time do not order from here!! If I could give 0 stars I would
Worlds best pizza. Great beer selection, the menu goes far beyond pizza but that is definitely their strong point in my opinion. Live bands and a beer garden 3 or 4 nights a week in the warmer months.
Homemade rootbeer. Need I say more?The pizza is uniquely crispy and textured in the crust. The personal size pizzas are the perfect size for one person. Two-three can split the medium easily. The wings are smoked and are awesome. I was personally was not a fan of how sweet the BBQ sauce is but to each their own.
Our food is ALWAYS incredible, but service is inconsistent. We love the gyro and taco pizzas! This past visit, our waitress never checked up on us, we werent brought silverware, napkins or drink refills. We will only be returning, because we love the pizza!
Stopped in for lunch today and both the food and service was good. I cant remember our servers name, but he was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back.
Horrible customer service! We drove 1.5 hours from Dayton area to meet with family and friends for Rockhouse. Reservations were mandatory in advance. Our reservation request was for the front of the stage (easier for our blind cousin) but was informed that Honda took precedent therefore, we were booted to the back! Thats fine whatever, but what really got us was that reservation time limits were not disclosed until checks were shoved under our noses and we were told to go sit at the bar. It wasnt that long after we recieved and barley finished our food before they wanted reset the table and began pushing us out!We moved to the bar as told with no chance to finish our drinks at our original table. We were attempting to find a seat but there were no seats for us, let alone our blind cousin! Yet there were seats for others??? We stood there trying to consume our $5.00 beverages quickly to leave (as there was no alternative) when management began yelling in my face with his mask below his nose! He was yelling at us to sit, so I asked him to provide us a seat and he refused. Yeah, makes sense right? 🤷♀️ Then he insisted that we discard our drinks and leave! They already got our money so out you go! The owner/manager began pointing his fingers in my childrens faces yelling Covid issues, yet he was far to close to for their safety! 🤷♀️ If it werent for the safety concerns of our blind cousin, I wouldve physically removed him from our personal spaces! How DARE him!!!! Ill will never step foot in that indecent, discriminatory, overpriced pizzeria again!!! Rockhouse was great but well see them, and spend our money elsewhere! Shame on you Bennys!
I grew up in Marysville, so Bennys is a household name. I think they rely on that fact, because when Bennys messes up my order, they push back on fixing it - no incentive to have great customer service when an army of folks are waiting behind you to pick up your pizza. I think theyd be well-served by a reminder that just because they are a local icon they cant just dismiss customer concerns.
Always good food and fast service.
Great pizza, great service
BBQ chicken 🐔 pizza was exceptional 👌
Went today with some friends and family to eat and listen to some live music. They had reserved a table for 5:30 with full intent to stay until the band stopped playing at 10:30. Our waitress came and took our orders, and as we were eating, she gave us our checks and informed us that our reservation ended at 7:30, which was not stated at the time of making the reservation. Apparently reservations rotate every two hours, which was also unknown to us. We asked her if we could still order drinks. She said yes, but the only seats we could get were at the bar. Already frustrated, we make our way to the bar only to find no seats open. We ended up standing at the bar so we could at least watch the band and finish our drinks. We were approached by an employee (I’m not sure if he was a manager or not) and told that we could not stand and drink at the same time. We had to be sitting. My mother asked for a seat, he responded by yelling and cussing in her face (not social distancing might I add) and pointed in me and my sisters face, which we are both minors. In the end, we were basically thrown out.So anyways, don’t recommend. Pizza wasn’t even that great :)
If this were an ordinary pizza place I would only give it two stars, but they truly have great food. The last time we went they forgot to put us on the wait list and people who were there much later than us got seated much early, we went and told them and they said they made an error and said we were next, but they forgot again! After an hour and 30 minutes we were seated and very happy with the food and our waiter.
Pizza is much better when you dine in or the dine in kitchen makes the pizza then the carry out. Im not sure if the ovens on the kitchen side are better. But when my pizza gets made there for carry out when carryout already breaks the kitchen down it taste much better. Love the old world pepperoni so much better the normal pepperoni is too greasy and gives me horrible heartburn.
I finally went to Bennys, after being told years ago that it is a must-go place. I had no idea how large the outdoor seating area was, or that they bring in great bands, or the fact that the pizza would be as great as the claims. Great place to take the family, or a fun adult night out. I cannot wait to go again.
I think that this is some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. Huge outdoor area and lots of other great menu items that look delicious and I have got tried yet.
Bennys is so friendly and casual. The pizza toppings are creative and classic. The evening supervisor, BP was super responsive to customer ambiance preferences. He was simply TUNED in to all of his guests! Kudos!
I am from Columbus but Was in Marysville for a my friends Fathers Memorial service. Went to Bennys afterwards and had a fantastic time. AMAZING pizza. Even more amazing staff. Felt absolutely treated like a regular even though that was my first time ever there. Thx again for the great hospitality. 😁👍✌
Fantastic food. The building is pretty small and dated. I enjoyed my sit in experience except for wait staff bumping into me because my chair was near a high traffic hallway. Get the pizza, but take it home. Luckily they have two kitchens, one for carry out and the other for dine in.
Nick from Bob Chapman Ford suggested we try Bennys Pizza for lunch. He was correct about how good the food is there.We hit about the lunch rush hour and the place was jumpin. Although they were crowded and very busy both the food and service was GREAT!The house rootbeer is excellent. The deep fried mushrooms were also very good. I personally tend to go for thick crust pizza but the thin crispy crust on their pizza was terrific.
Great food, cold beer, friendly bartenders.What more could you want after a long day at work.
Pizza was amazing...didnt think that it was going to be so large
The place was packed,they had a line for carryout and yet they remade our pizza because it had olives on it😝. Not sure what my husband ordered but they graciously took responsibility and made us a new one. It was a shame that I wasnt feeling well enough to enjoy it. We will be back.
Great food and even better service!
Bennys Pizza is hands down the BEST eatery for your pizza and sandwich needs! Ive tried almost everything on the menu and havent been let down a single time. Try the Spinach Dip, out of this world!
We ordered the loaded cheese fries, wings, 5 meat pizza, and the BLT pizza. Everything was amazing! Bennys is our favorite pizza place hands down. Incredible food and good service.
Went there yesterday for first time. Ordered wings and pizza. Wings were huge and pizza was awesome. Great service and great food. Will definitely be returning soon.
Ordered a taco salad. They didn’t bring me dressing. I asked for some ranch. They charged me 50¢ per container. Did not tell me it was an additional charge. Manager wouldn’t take it off my bill. Even scoffed, rolling her eyes saying, “It’s just 50 cents.” Sorry, every dollar counts in my family. Eating out is a luxury. I will be taking my money elsewhere where my business is appreciated. There are much better, cleaner pizza places in Marysville than this.
Denise was great... Chicken BBQ pizza was Awesome great job, thank you.. when we visit from PA.. we always come to eat at Bennys. Keep up the great work 👍 👏 💪
You cannot beat Bennys pizza in the Marysville area! Just cant happen! The staff is very friendly but not over bearing. The restaurant itself has that X factor charm, and the prices are great. Highly recommended for a great night out!
Best damn pizza in Ohio
Ordered a large garbage pizza and it was perfect with a very crispy crust. Wife ordered a philly cheese steak sandwich with straight cut fries and it came out with curly fries and the sandwich came out without cheese or toppings. Her order was replaced but had next to no toppings on the sandwich and the bread was soggy.
If I lived in Marysville, I would weigh 500 pounds. The pizza is legendary but many people never get to find out that their smoked wings are some of the best ever. The staff is always friendly...even hilarious. Vicky is without a doubt one of the coolest managers on the scene. She always picks great local beers and make sure that new things are getting rotated in
Bennys is just a great place . Ive been going there for years & never had a problem with any thing. Great pizza.& they have damn good ribs. Plus its a great place to have a large get together
Im not local and was recommend this place to eat. Man am I glad I went. Got the smoked wings and a small pie and it was ready in under 20 minutes. Absolutely awesome pizza for the money. Wings some of the best I have ever eaten.
They have great pizza!! They also have some of there own craft beers. The staff was excellent! And giving a shout out to the tall beautiful sever with brown and purple hair great service!
A friend recommended Benny. My wife abed I had yet to find good pizza in Ohio. (Im from Pittsburgh sheets theres plenty.)w thought East of Chicago was decent but went to Benny yesterday. The pizza was Amazing! I little hot inside though.
I heard a lot about their Pizza Is really Good Today I drive Across Marysville then I try BBQ Chicken Pizza absolutely the Best I recommend. Can’t wait to try other kind of pizza from them🍕😋
Amazing pizza. But they are getting rid of the family size pizza. (18 inches). This is usually what I order, because its cheaper than two larges and the perfect amount of pizza. Family gatherings we can get a couple of those, if we have to get more larges it may become too expensive and have to take our business elsewhere. Such as tubbys who still has 18 inch pizzas. Dont get rid of the family size pizza!
As a non-local, I was taken to Bennys by someone from the Marysville area. The homemade rootbeer is amazing! I had a brisket sandwich, which was alright (the meat was a little dry) but the chips that came with it were over seasoned for sure. Overall, its a cute little restaurant with a great atmosphere.
Total reviews rating 4.6
199 Reviews for Bennys Pizza 2023:
Review №1
2022-07-10Had the opportunity to go to Bennys with my coworkers today. Have to say the food was very very good. I had the bbq pork sandwich! Best bbq I have had since moving here to Ohio! Only downfall was the inside of this fine establishment was packed so we had to sit outside. It was very chilly. On a nice day I would imagine it was be very nice! I have to say I really would come back here to dine inside on a cold day or outside on a nicer day !
Review №2
2022-06-29First time visit, came highly recommended.. great staff good mix of food on the menu, personal pan pizza to full pies, went with the All the way was very good. Would definitely go again.. oh and live music was good too.
Review №3
2022-01-02Best BLT pizza Ive ever had. Waitress was really on top of it. Fast service in a busy place. All the staff was super friendly. I cant wait to go back!
Review №4
2022-04-21I must admit I belong to a pizza group and this location comes up often!! I had never tried this pizza. This pizza place is so big that it has two different buildings. One for dine in. One for takeout. When you enter the takeout side you are offered a free vanilla or chocolate cone. The pizza was ready before when I arrived. I had to take a bite in the car. I think I went to pizza heaven for a second. This pizza melted in my mouth. The perfect combination of sauce, cheese, pepperoni and sausage. Please give this place a try!!
Review №5
2022-07-03Stopped by after many years. Benny’s never disappoints! Our server, Denise, was amazing! Very personable and attentive during our visit. The Alaskan Ale was a perfect pair with our pretzel and pizza. I can’t say enough about the 5 meat pizza! We added mushrooms and onions to ours and had a medium. We ended up bringing 1/2 of it home with us. If your ever close by, or even far away, it’s worth the drive!!
Review №6
2022-07-07This was my first time to eat at Benny’s. Food was really good but the waitress was the best. I wish I remembered her name but she is also a hairdresser. She did a great job interacting with us and sharing the specials for the day. She was attentive and kept checking on us. They have a great outdoor eating area with lots of space. I got a ham & cheese sub which was really good. The nachos looked amazing. I would go back here!
Review №7
2022-07-21Always had good service at Bennys the food quality is good awesome pizza. However, staff on Wednesday are young and act like they are bored being there. And the waitress who tried to keep my change as her tip needs a reality check. What planet do you live on to think you deserve a 50% tip. Food awesome.... Staff I think you can blame on this generation.
Review №8
2022-03-053/4/22 6:48pm was the date and approx time of our visitOur waitress was Chloe S. , that night !!!!!*She’s the only reason I gave 5 starsWow … what a great night when it came to food and service from her . She was outstanding never had to ask for refills, silverware, plates , etc . She was so nice , respectful and professional. Prior to sitting down though one of the managers and several staff members gave dirty looks to my wife because she was speaking to me about how the exits and entrances were crowded and people where coming in and out both ways and we was trying to get to the host stand . We don’t come there very often because we feel there are better pizza joints in town that do a better job all the around not just with food and service , atmosphere and respectful staff goes a long way as well, And pricing is way more there as well . I also feel that it’s always crowded and the layout of the restaurant is horrible, hince why it’s crowded with nowhere too stand , there’s just no good flow with customers and staff . And that’s why we don’t visit very often.
Review №9
2022-05-06Always have been the best pizza place around, but tonight was above and beyond. We had 20+ ppl in our party and even being under staffed the service was phenomenal. Drinks, apps, and main course were all right and very timely. Well done to the whole Bennys staff that took care of us, but especially to our waitress. You killed it sis.
Review №10
2022-06-05Quick service. Lots of outside seating which is really nice. Pizza was good, missed their having my favorite (taco pizza) from them on the menu. It used to be a regular but now is a special only.The patio was perfect ok a nice day in Marysville, they also have ample parking and lots of different types of food on the menu.